Former Moscow rabbi says he rebuffed proposal to convert a million Russians discussed in Epstein files recording

JTA – When newly released audio recordings revealed former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak discussing mass conversion and selective immigration with Jeffrey Epstein, disgraced financier and convicted sex trafficker, the reaction in Israel was swift and deeply political. 

Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, accused Barak of seeking to “select” Jews for immigration and charged that Israel’s political left was trying to “replace the people” after failing at the ballot box, an echo of contemporary conspiracy theories about immigration that appear to have been treated as a serious idea at the time. 

The recordings, released this week as part of the United States Justice Department’s latest disclosure under the Epstein Files Transparency Act, capture Barak in a wide-ranging conversation with Epstein, who died in federal custody in 2019. The audio appears to date to about 2013, when Barak – a longtime leader in the liberal Labor Party – was 71 years old and transitioning into the private sector. 

In the recording, Barak argues that Israel should weaken the Orthodox rabbinate’s control over conversion and open the door to large-scale conversion as a demographic strategy. 

“We have to break the monopoly of the Orthodox rabbinate – on marriage and funerals, the definition of a Jew,” Barak says. “Open the gates for massive conversion into Judaism. It’s a successful country. Many will apply.” 

Over more than three hours, Barak speaks candidly about population trends in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza, warning that without a two-state solution, Jews could lose their demographic majority. 

“It will be an Arab majority,” Barak says of the territories. “It’s a collective blindness of our society.” 

Barak also expresses concern about the growing proportion of Arab citizens within Israel, noting that Arabs made up about 16% of the population four decades ago and roughly 20% then. He contrasts that growth with the ultra-Orthodox Jewish population, which he says is expanding more rapidly. 

As a counterweight, Barak proposes immigration, conversion, and minority inclusion. He praises the Druze and Christian minorities as highly integrated, and points to immigrants from the former Soviet Union as prime candidates for conversion. 

“We can control the quality much more effectively, much more than the founding fathers of Israel did,” Barak says. Referring explicitly to immigration from North Africa, he says, “They took whatever came just to save people. Now, we can be more selective.” 

Barak lauds the post-Soviet aliya of the 1990s, which brought more than one million Russian-speaking immigrants to Israel, and says the country could “easily absorb another million”. He recounts telling Russian President Vladimir Putin about this idea, and joking about mixed Russian-Israeli names in the military as evidence of rapid integration. 

The remarks drew sharp criticism from Pinchas Goldschmidt, who spent more than three decades leading Moscow’s Jewish community before leaving the country after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022. In an interview, Goldschmidt said the recording echoed conversations he encountered repeatedly during his years in Russia. 

“I spent 33 years in Moscow, and there was talk like this,” Goldschmidt said. “Not necessarily among the heads of the agencies dealing with aliya, but among employees and officials who felt this was their opportunity to stop Israel from becoming a Levantine country.” 

Goldschmidt said those attitudes occasionally surfaced in direct encounters with Israeli political figures. He recalled a meeting with former Israeli Minister Haim Ramon, who asked whether Orthodox rabbinical courts could convert large numbers of non-Jewish immigrants from the former Soviet Union. 

“He came to me with a number,” Goldschmidt said. “He mentioned 100 000.” 

Goldschmidt said his response was categorical. “Halacha doesn’t speak in numbers,” he said. “There is no number on the top, and no number on the bottom. Halacha speaks about standards and conditions. If one million people are ready to convert according to Jewish law, then we will convert one million people. And if they are not ready, we will not convert even one.” 

Goldschmidt said the meeting took place after Ramon had left government following a sexual misconduct scandal, but emphasised that it was not a casual exchange. 

“It was more than a conversation,” he said. “It wasn’t a conversation over tea. If he came to see me officially with a question like that on the table, then it meant something.” 

For Goldschmidt, Barak’s claim in the recording that he discussed such matters with Putin was particularly striking. “Why do you have to speak to Putin about converting a million Russians?” he asked. “People can leave Russia without permission. The person he needed to speak to was me.” 

Goldschmidt said Barak’s framing of conversion and immigration would be widely perceived in Israel as offensive. “Anyone from Middle Eastern backgrounds would hear this whole conversation as extremely racist,” he said. “And anyone who is traditional or religious would also find it very offensive.” 

In his comments, Netanyahu also said Barak’s close relationship with Epstein proved that Epstein didn’t work for Israel or its intelligence services, saying it would make no sense for an Israeli asset to be closely associated with one of the government’s most vocal opponents. 

Barak’s ties to Epstein – including repeated meetings years after Epstein’s 2008 conviction – have been reported previously, and there is no evidence of criminal wrongdoing by Barak.