OSS publish report, recommendations on Israel

  • OSS Logo HOME
An SA fact-finding mission to Israel and the occupied territories, facilitated by Open Shuhada Street (OSS) and the Heinrich Boll Foundation, issued a scathing report this week stating that “Occupation must be made economically, politically and morally costly for Israel”. Ten of the 11 delegates signed and endorsed a report and recommendations published by OSS this week. The exception was DA KwaZulu-Natal MPL (and ex-DA Youth leader) Mbali Ntuli.
by ANT KATZ | Nov 04, 2014

The eleven delegates visited between October 21 and 29. Last week Jewish Report reported that an executive of the anti-Israel Media Review Network, Iqbal Jassat (who was not among the visitors), published a story “SA fact-finding mission in Israel raises Palestinian hopes” on Politicsweb on October 27, two days before the group returned – pre-empting their report.

This week’s report by OSS, “Prominent South Africans express support for international BDS campaign until international law is observed”, was predictable.

OSS LogoThe delegation consisted of former anti-apartheid activists Barney Pityana, Vusi Pikoli and Firoz Cachalia; civil society leaders Vuyiseka Dubula, Brad Brockman and Adila Hassim; politician Mbali Ntuli; author and political analyst Christi van der Westhuizen; and activists Adaiah Lilenstein, Bruce Baigrie and Keren Ben-Zeev.

They met Israeli and Palestinian civil society organisations, activists, politicians and local people to discuss the different dimensions of the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza. Regrettably the delegation was unable to enter Gaza due to the time constraints caused by the stringent permit conditions.

The Statement by OSS reads as follows:

PLEASE NOTE: This statement represents our personal views and not necessarily the official positions of any organisations we might be attached to or those that facilitated the visit.

Based on our visits to Tel Aviv, East Jerusalem and the West Bank, our observations are the following:

  • Israeli and Palestinian leaders agreed on a two-state solution in the Oslo Accords of 1993, in which a five year process would have culminated in an independent Palestinian state encompassing the West Bank and Gaza. The visit made it clear to the delegation that Israel's military occupation and expanding settlement of the West Bank and East Jerusalem is eroding the viability of the two-state solution.
  • Instead of finding the Palestinian Authority in charge of the West Bank, the delegation realised the Israeli government and the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) are in control of military and civilian affairs of the Palestinian population. Soldiers are seen everywhere. The West Bank is dotted with a network of military checkpoints, surveillance cameras, watch towers, segregated roads and a very high concrete wall that cuts across the territory annexing parts of the West Bank, including East Jerusalem (part of the Palestinian territory according to international law), to Israel. Palestinians' movement is restricted through a permit system and IDs that relegate them to residents, as opposed to citizens. We witnessed Palestinians being herded through checkpoints in a system that is no better than cattle pens.
  • Palestinian civilians are under military law, which is discretionary and arbitrary and they rely on the institutions of the Israeli occupation for most services, as the Palestinian Authority has limited powers. Israeli military courts are run by soldiers and traffic offences are tried by military courts, which have no system of due process and do not comply with the rule of law. People resisting the occupation are also tried in the military courts.
  • They are detained in terms of military codes and face random decisions and postponing of their cases or procedures such as "administrative detention", which potentially leaves them imprisoned for indefinite periods without access to proper legal representation. Interrogation and torture are routinely used. Applications for permits to leave the West Bank for work and other purposes have to be made to the military administration. In contrast, Israeli settlers in the West Bank are under civilian law and enjoy all basic rights like their fellow Israeli citizens. The Israeli cabinet is currently considering a bill to restrict the independence of the court.
  • In most of the areas that the delegation visited - East Jerusalem, Jordan Valley, Hebron and villages outside of Ramallah - we saw how settlements work on the ground. The number of settlers in the West Bank including East Jerusalem currently stands at over 515 000. The Jordan Valley has huge agricultural settlements in a water-scarce area. We were shocked to find out that Israeli settlers are allocated on average 6 times the amount of water than Palestinians whose usage is limited to 23 litres per day in some areas.
  • Palestinians also on average pay three times the price for their water. Palestinians cannot build their homes, improve their access to water or engage in agricultural activities freely. In East Jerusalem and Hebron we saw how religious zealots physically displaced Palestinians with the support of the military. Many settlements include military bases. Soldiers and settlers are both armed, leaving Palestinians unprotected in the eye of violent acts of settlers.
  • Between 2004 and 2014, 517 Palestinian homes in East Jerusalem have been demolished, leaving 2 028 people homeless, over half of whom were minors. During the delegation's visit, the Israeli government announced the construction of another 1 000 settler homes in East Jerusalem, the internationally recognised future capital of the Palestinian state. The delegation met with families physically displaced by Israelis who have invaded their homes, while soldiers were patrolling the area.
  • It has become clear to us through our visit that the settlement process and the mass dispossession and displacement of Palestinians are directly opposed to the goal of a two-state solution. It seems to be aimed either at the forcible transfer of the Palestinian population, which amounts to continuing ethnic cleansing or at the very least, the containment of Palestinians in a system of fragmented cantons. Violent suppression of demonstrations against dispossession and displacement is backed up by draconian military law.
  • Palestinians are criminalised even when resisting the occupation without force and a staggering one-fifth of the population of the West Bank has been incarcerated since 1967. There are currently 6 200 political prisoners.
  • The delegation's visit to the Ofer military court revealed that these courts operate on the presumption of guilt in a hopelessly unjust administrative process controlled by soldiers. This is confirmed by the conviction rate of 99,7 per cent.
  • Particularly abominable is the Israeli Defence Forces' targeting of Palestinian children. An estimated 2 500 Palestinian children have been arrested between 2010 to mid-2014. Approximately 400 children were between the ages of 12 and 15 years but some were as young as 5. Children are subject to torture and interrogation. Intimidation includes threats of sexual violence. While the delegation was in Hebron, an 11-year-old child was arrested by the military on his way to school and held without his parents or any legal representation for hours. We heard many accounts and were shown footage of these abuses.
  • It became clear to the delegation that Israel and the West Bank form one territory that is fragmented through a system of regulation and physical control through which resources such as fertile lands, water and state revenues are extracted for the benefit of Israeli citizens at the expense of Palestinians. These steps deepen the poverty and economic marginalisation of Palestinians. In Hebron we even saw how shops and market places are shut down in service of the grand design of the Israeli security state.
  • Across class and geography, the Palestinians we met were clear they would be willing to live peacefully side by side with Jews, either in two states, a bi-national state or one state. As a nation which struggled and continues to struggle for justice, peace and human rights we have a particular responsibility to speak out on injustice where it is evident. As such, we call on South Africans, Israeli citizens and the global community to support the transition to a just and peaceful resolution that recognises Palestinians' claims to human rights.  

The delegation calls for:

  • An immediate end to the military occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, which remains under illegal blockade, and the removal of all settlements.
  • The Israeli government as well as Palestinian ruling factions to uphold the rule of law and to respect and protect Palestinians' human rights under international law. All political prisoners must be released.
  • Support for the international Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions campaign against Israel until international law is observed. Israeli society continues to largely be complicit in the maintenance of the Occupation and Israeli politics remains dominated by the right and ultra-right parties. Thus the international community must make the occupation economically, politically and morally costly for Israel until it is dismantled.
  • The South African government to consistently apply all relevant legislation, including the Foreign Military Assistance Act.
  • After we have seen the reality on the ground in the occupied Palestinian territories, we hereby express our solidarity with the Palestinian people in their struggle for self-determination.

The statement was signed and endorsed by ten of the delegates: Adaiah Lilenstein , Adv. Adila Hassim - Section 27, Prof. Barney Pityana , Brad Brockman - Equal Education, Bruce Baigrie - Open Shuhada Street, Dr Christi van der Westhuizen - Author and political analyst, Prof Firoz Cachalia - Wits School of Law, Keren Ben-Zeev, Adv. Vusi Pikoli  and Vuyiseka Dubula from Sonke Gender Justice and Treatment Action Campaign.

The eleventh delegate, the DA KwaZulu-MPL Mbali Ntuli, neither signed nor endorsed the statement.



  1. 2 Ed 04 Nov
    they should also visit Syria and condemn the war atrocities and violations of human rights there as well as Qatar and Saudi Arabia
    A more worthy visit would be to Zimbabwe
  2. 1 Gary Selikow 05 Nov
    Another Jew-hating (YES-JEW HATING) genocidal hate delegation to Israel to spread lies and hate


  1. RadEditor - HTML WYSIWYG Editor. MS Word-like content editing experience thanks to a rich set of formatting tools, dropdowns, dialogs, system modules and built-in spell-check.
    RadEditor's components - toolbar, content area, modes and modules
    Toolbar's wrapper 
    Content area wrapper
    RadEditor's bottom area: Design, Html and Preview modes, Statistics module and resize handle.
    It contains RadEditor's Modes/views (HTML, Design and Preview), Statistics and Resizer
    Editor Mode buttonsStatistics moduleEditor resizer
    RadEditor's Modules - special tools used to provide extra information such as Tag Inspector, Real Time HTML Viewer, Tag Properties and other.


Follow us on