Jews in Hong Kong apathetic about protests

  • JTAHongKong
(JTA) Since early June, protesters in Hong Kong have been gathering multiple times a week to fight what they see as Chinese attempts to encroach on their freedom. The police have responded violently at times, shooting tear gas and rubber bullets at the crowd.
by JOSEFIN DOLSTEN | Aug 29, 2019

One demonstration drew an estimated two million protesters in a population of 7.3 million.

But for most members of the Jewish community in Hong Kong, life has gone on without much change.

“That’s the crazy thing about the situation, there is a revolution taking place but actually our lives have continued as normal,” said Ben Freeman, a Glasgow native who has been living in Hong Kong for the past two years.

Hong Kong, a one-time British colony now controlled by China and given limited autonomy, is home to about 5 000 Jews and a number of Jewish institutions. There are seven congregations – orthodox, Chabad and progressive – a Jewish community centre, school, and Holocaust centre. But none of the organisations are located in the areas where protests are happening, and business is operating largely as usual.

“I went for Shabbat dinner on Friday night at a friend’s house, and of course we talk about it, but nothing is happening to expats, so there’s definitely a feeling of safety,” Freeman, who works as a teacher at an international school, told the Jewish Telegraphic Agency (JTA).

They aren’t the only ones who are largely unaffected by the protests. In spite of media coverage surrounding the at times bloody clashes with police, restaurants, malls, and business establishments continue to operate in relative normality. Schools are due to open next week.

The protests started in reaction to the effort by the China-backed government to allow extraditions to China. It led to fears that China could extradite dissenters and government critics taking refuge in the more politically open Hong Kong.

Protesters have since added a number of other demands, including universal suffrage in the city that would allow its citizens to vote for its leader, the chief executive. The post is now selected by a group of about 1 200 prominent professionals and members of the legislative council, most of whom are loyal to China.

Though some in the Jewish community might support the protesters’ efforts, they tend to stay away like other expats, said David Zweig, a professor emeritus of Chinese politics at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology. Zweig has participated in two protests, but said he was the exception rather than the rule.

“The safest general statement is that expats don’t get involved at all,” he told JTA. “Some Jewish expats might be sympathetic to the young people – those would be people who pay attention to politics and realise that Beijing is tightening up – but there are a lot of people who simply look at this from a business perspective, and this hurts business.”

The Jewish community is diverse, with members hailing from Europe, North America, South America, Australia, South Africa, and Israel. Many work in banking, finance, law, and business.

Erica Lyons, the chairperson of the Jewish Historical Society of Hong Kong, said the transiency of the community and the fact that few of them speak Cantonese are among the reasons they don’t get involved in the protests.

“The general feeling is support of [the protesters] but not involvement,” said Lyons, who comes from New Jersey in the United States.

Some community members do get involved. Nicole Izsak attended about 15 protests this summer prior to moving to New York a month ago for her husband’s job.

Most were peaceful, but a few times she clashed with police. On 12 June, Izsak was with a large group of protesters when police started approaching them with batons and tear gas. The crowd was pushed onto a small footbridge, where Izsak feared she could be crushed by the large mass of people.

“I need to get out of here,” she recalled thinking.

But the experience didn’t deter Izsak, a Londoner who lived in Hong Kong for 10 years, from participating again.

“We benefited from freedoms of speech, assembly, [and] the privilege of living there, and we should give back to the community that gave us so much,” she said.

Izsak, who has worked for Hong Kong’s Jewish school, Jewish women’s association, and the Jewish film festival, said her Jewish identity had also played a role in her participation.

“As a Jewish person, I believe in taking a stand,” she said.

Izsak has heard a range of reasons why Jews in Hong Kong prefer to stay out of politics.

“I think it varies between disinterest, feeling it’s not their issue, feeling they don’t have the right to do it, feeling that Jews should keep their heads below the parapet, or not supporting the demonstrations,” she said.

For Freeman, the Scottish Jew who teaches at an international school, safety concerns trump other factors.

“We’re staying away because it’s not necessarily safe,” he said. “To be quite honest, I’d be very nervous to go down to a protest.”


  1. RadEditor - HTML WYSIWYG Editor. MS Word-like content editing experience thanks to a rich set of formatting tools, dropdowns, dialogs, system modules and built-in spell-check.
    RadEditor's components - toolbar, content area, modes and modules
    Toolbar's wrapper 
    Content area wrapper
    RadEditor's bottom area: Design, Html and Preview modes, Statistics module and resize handle.
    It contains RadEditor's Modes/views (HTML, Design and Preview), Statistics and Resizer
    Editor Mode buttonsStatistics moduleEditor resizer
    RadEditor's Modules - special tools used to provide extra information such as Tag Inspector, Real Time HTML Viewer, Tag Properties and other.


My Place advert 300px x 300px 110820



Yad Aharon GENERIC2020


Follow us on