Religion Featured Item 

Overheard at President's Chanukah parties

  • WW1 - Jabotinsky
(i) The Senate is sending a rabbi to a Buddhist nation to tell them not to persecute its Muslim minority; (ii) Obama was heard to mutter he felt Jewish “in my soul”.
by ANT KATZ | Dec 21, 2014

The tradition of holding Washington White House Chanukah party was started by President George W Bush. Since then, the party has actually expanded into two parties: one in the afternoon and one in the evening.

WW1 - Jewish legion posterThis year the mood was particularly up-beat, given that the parties were on the same day that Alan Gross was released from five years in a Cuban prison.

President Obama, who earned enthusiastic cheers at both parties, is still a smart enough politician to have played that to the hilt.

“I’m told that in the Jewish tradition, one of the great mitzvahs is ‘pidyon shvuyim,’ ” he said to applause at the afternoon party. “My Hebrew is not perfect, but I get points for trying. But it describes the redemption, the freeing, of captives. And that’s what we’re celebrating today, because after being unjustly held in Cuba for more than five years, American Alan Gross is free.”

Obama emphasized a Jewish tradition: food

“I spoke to [Gross] on his flight. He said he was willing to interrupt his corned beef sandwich to talk to me. I told him he had mustard in his moustache; I couldn’t actually see it,” the president said.

Then it was back to the theme of freedom, with a deft pivot to his controversial reversal Wednesday of decades of U.S. policy isolating Cuba:

“He’s back where he belongs — in America, with his family, home for Chanukah,” Obama said. “And I can’t think of a better way to mark this holiday, with its message that freedom is possible, than with the historic changes that I announced today in our Cuba policy.”

Playing to his audience, back to the food:

“So what brings us together is not just lox and latkes, although I have heard the latkes here are outstanding.” (The latkes, like Gross and the president, got applause.) “Am I wrong? Not as good as your mom’s, but they’re good. We’re here to celebrate a story that took place more than 2,000 years ago, when a small group of Maccabees rose up to defeat their far more powerful oppressors.”

Partygoers – over 500 for each celebration — were jubilant, and not just because of the season and the good news. The hour-long line through security, winding from outside the adjacent Treasury building, was made pleasant by sunny, unseasonably warm weather.

Invitees enter the East Wing and may tour the rooms decked out in Christmas decorations, which attract the attention of even the most Yuletide averse – who could resist the robotic version of the Obama family pooches, Bo and Sunny? And then there is the massive gingerbread White House – presumably not certified kosher, but who would dare take a bite?

There was plenty of kosher food to be had, including latkes, tender lamb chops with cranberry sauce and aromatic smoked salmon.

There was some visual and aural relief from Christmas themes, including Tizmoret, a vocal group from the City University of New York’s Queens College Hillel. The group serenaded the guests as they entered an alcove on the way to the main reception, where the four Chanukias were on display – three made by Israeli children.

Guests at the afternoon included numerous journalists and Jewish Democratic cognoscenti,  among them Ann Lewis, an adviser to Hillary Rodham Clinton; Reva Price, an adviser to Rep. Nancy Pelosi, the House minority leader; and Rabbi Jack Moline, who just ended a stint as director of the National Jewish Democratic Council.


Rabbi is longest serving faith-based lobbyist

Also in attendance was Rabbi David Saperstein, finishing up four decades of service with the Reform movement’s Religious Action Centre (making him the longest serving faith-based lobbyist in town) now that the Senate confirmed him last week as a special envoy for religious freedom.

Asked where he was first headed in his new role, Rabbi Saperstein answered “Burma,” to discuss the Mohingar.

So the Senate is sending a rabbi to a Buddhist nation to tell them not to persecute its Muslim minority.

The other message of this year’s Chanukah season is that it seems everyone is Jewish. On Tuesday JTA wrote that Vice President Joe Biden told celebrants at Chabad’s annual National Menorah lighting on the Ellipse that “Jewish heritage is American heritage”. The Los Angeles Jewish Journal’s David Suissa captured this gem from the evening White House party:


‘I didn’t know the president was Jewish’

“Mr President,” [a man standing next to Suissa] said in his booming voice, “when I told my Christian friend I was coming to a Chanukah party at the White House, he told me: ‘I didn’t know the president was Jewish’!”

The president let out a serious belly laugh. But in all the commotion of people asking other questions and everyone clicking their smartphone cameras, it was easy to lose sight of the president to see if he had anything to say.

The “president was Jewish” idea had intrigued him. After about three or four seconds, as he was walking away, and looking at no one in particular, the president just said: “I am, in my soul.”

Israeli schools figured in the candle-lighting at both parties: Hand in Hand, the Arab-Jewish school that was the target of a recent arson attack, was represented by two of its ninth-graders at the first reception, and Yemin Orde, Israel’s school for recent olim, sent a student to light a candle at the second party. Also lighting a candle at the second party was Adam Levine, a professor of emergency medicine at Brown who recently returned from Liberia, where he was treating Ebola patients.

“Now I just want to be clear, this is not Adam Levine, People magazine’s Sexiest Man Alive,” Obama helpfully explained.

Seekers of Hollywood glitter at the second party at least got a glimpse of Gwyneth Paltrow – invited, perhaps, because of her recently announced conversion plans.

“Oh, she’s from ‘Iron Man” one youngster present noted, according to his dad, Nathan Diament, the Orthodox Union’s Washington director.


  1. 3 Gary Selikow 21 Dec
     The Senate is sending a Rabbi to a Buddhist nation to tell them not to persecute its Muslim minority;
    but both Obama and this Rabbi have never tried to act on behalf of the many minorities persecuted in Muslim nations, including the Copts, Maronies, Bahais, Yazidis, Buddhists , Hindus, Christians in Nigeria, Pakistan and Indonesia to name a few
  2. 2 david 23 Dec
    No at all difficult to believe that Obama would send a Rabbi to talk and negotiate with the Burmese on behalf of the Muslim minority.
    Selecting picture opportunities are Obama's speciality , as well as showboating to his constituency. As Gary asks, why not the many minorities, not only persecuted, but tortured and killed by Muslims in the  name of one Muslim faction or another?
    As many of us have believed for the length of Obama's tenure, he is the expert at speaking with 'forked silver tongue'.  He sits in his Ivory tower and dispenses his public, justice priorities and wants us to believe that he is 'our' friend.
    We need to be selective in terming him 'our friend' until we get the opportunity to understand his agenda, which is so far under extreme question. 
  3. 1 Lenny G 23 Dec
    The rabbi wouldn't stand a chance if he went to a Muslim nation. If he wasn't banned from entering they would throw him in jail the minute he set foot in whatever country.


  1. RadEditor - HTML WYSIWYG Editor. MS Word-like content editing experience thanks to a rich set of formatting tools, dropdowns, dialogs, system modules and built-in spell-check.
    RadEditor's components - toolbar, content area, modes and modules
    Toolbar's wrapper 
    Content area wrapper
    RadEditor's bottom area: Design, Html and Preview modes, Statistics module and resize handle.
    It contains RadEditor's Modes/views (HTML, Design and Preview), Statistics and Resizer
    Editor Mode buttonsStatistics moduleEditor resizer
    RadEditor's Modules - special tools used to provide extra information such as Tag Inspector, Real Time HTML Viewer, Tag Properties and other.


Follow us on