Lifestyle/Community
Chance encounter becomes a legacy of Jewish wisdom
A chance encounter between a critically ill secular Jewish woman and a rabbi became an extraordinary friendship, a spiritual journey, and, ultimately, a book intended to help people confront antisemitism through goodness.
Australian journalist Nikki Goldstein discussed her book Conversations with my Rabbi, with Niki Seberini during a webinar hosted by Chabad House Johannesburg. The book grew out of her relationship with Rabbi Eli Schlanger, who was killed in the terrorist attack at Bondi Beach on 14 December 2025.
Their connection began years earlier, when Goldstein was critically ill in hospital with chronic lung disease. After her oxygen levels plummeted, doctors warned her family that she would die without being intubated. She was placed in an induced coma.
Her daughter noticed Rabbi Schlanger walking past the hospital room and asked her father, who isn’t Jewish, if they should approach him to pray for her mother. Goldstein’s husband immediately leapt up and approached Schlanger.
Goldstein’s family didn’t know her Hebrew name or her mother’s Hebrew name, but Schlanger prayed for her and blew a shofar in the intensive care unit, as it was Elul at the time. About 24 hours later, Goldstein began recovering. When she eventually woke, she told her family that she had felt the prayers.
She later met Schlanger, who was delighted that she had survived. Their conversations developed into a close friendship.
Goldstein described the rabbi as someone who didn’t simply believe in G-d, but was “absolutely saturated in G-d”. Although she had always been curious about Judaism, she wasn’t observant. Her relationship with Schlanger changed her understanding of religion. “I haven’t become more observant, but I’ve become more religious,” she said.
Schlanger never pressured her to become more religious. Instead, they spoke openly about faith, morality, relationships, and the challenges of being Jewish. Towards the end of 2024, Schlanger encouraged Goldstein to write a book with him. Rising antisemitism and the questions facing Jewish people after the Hamas-led attacks on 7 October had made him increasingly concerned about how to offer meaningful answers.
Goldstein suggested a book built around their conversations and the seven Noahide laws. These are universal moral principles in Jewish tradition, understood to have been given to humanity by G-d after the flood. The laws prohibit idolatry, blasphemy, murder, theft, sexual immorality, and eating flesh from a living animal. They also require the establishment of systems of justice.
Schlanger wanted to explore how these principles could speak to contemporary life. He and Goldstein discussed how idolatry could include placing money, possessions, celebrity, or status above everything else. They also examined people’s responsibility for their use of language, particularly online, and the importance of treating animals and the natural world with care. One question that emerged was “What do we give our deepest yes to?”.
For Schlanger, recognising G-d meant recognising the divine in the world and in other people. He encouraged his children to be conscious of G-d’s presence in everything, even a leaf they absent-mindedly pulled from a tree.
The conversations weren’t always easy. Goldstein said they had disagreed on issues including sexuality, marriage, and Jewish law. She raised concerns about how traditional religious views might affect her gay nephew.
As a modern, secular woman, she was accustomed to making her own decisions. Schlanger approached these questions from his religious tradition. Goldstein wanted the book to preserve their differences rather than present an artificial agreement. Their friendship depended on honesty and the freedom to challenge one another.
The writing process was interrupted by the attack at Bondi Beach, where Schlanger was one of 15 people killed during a Chanukah celebration. Goldstein and her husband had been invited to attend Chanukah by the Sea but had decided not to go after having lunch with other journalists. They arrived home at about 18:40, around the time the shooting began.
Goldstein’s last conversation with Schlanger had been four days before.
She later spoke to a young rabbi who had witnessed Schlanger’s final moments. When the shooting began, people sought cover. A young policeman and a rabbi were shot, and the wounded rabbi was trying to help the policeman. Schlanger emerged from hiding, raised his hands, and approached the gunman. He attempted to negotiate, saying, “There has to be another way.” He was trying to protect the two wounded men when he was fatally shot.
Goldstein said Schlanger had encountered the darkest aspects of humanity through his work as a prison chaplain. Yet he had continued to believe that people could choose goodness and that he could make a difference.
After his death, Goldstein returned to their recorded conversations. She realised they contained enough material to complete the book. With the approval of Schlanger’s widow and other family members, she approached a literary agent and secured a publishing deal within 24 hours.
Schlanger’s father-in-law, Rabbi Yehoram Ulman, wrote the final chapter, which focuses on justice. Rabbi Zalman Shmotkin helped check the religious content. Goldstein was determined to preserve Schlanger’s words and the authenticity of their conversations. She felt a particular responsibility to his children, including his youngest, who was two months old when he died.
The book’s publication has evoked complicated emotions. Goldstein misses her friend, but has also felt supported by the Jewish community and the many rabbis who have embraced the project. Schlanger had wanted the book to reach beyond the Jewish community. His wish was for it to be available in Jewish households, and for every Jew to give a copy to someone who isn’t Jewish.
For Goldstein, its message is particularly relevant amid rising antisemitism. She believes that responding to hatred with more hatred will achieve little. “Let’s not meet darkness with darkness, let’s meet darkness with light,” Schlanger told her.
She urges people to make goodness part of their everyday choices; through kindness, compassion, and the way they treat others. “If you don’t like the word G-d, then just replace it with good, because it’s the same thing,” she said.
A friendship that began with prayers beside a hospital bed is now preserved in a book carrying Schlanger’s message beyond his lifetime: that even in the face of darkness, people can choose to bring light.