Sinead O’Connor – the incomparable nemesis of Israeli right
JTA – Over the course of Irish pop singer Sinead O’Connor’s career, she made her fair share of enemies, most notably the Catholic Church, after ripping up a picture of the pope on Saturday Night Live.
But five years after that incident, she also found herself in the crosshairs of Israel’s future national security minister.
O’Connor, who died on Wednesday 26 July at the age of 56, had in 1997 planned to perform a concert in Jerusalem sponsored by a women-led activist group promoting peace between Israel and the Palestinians. But she cancelled the show after receiving scores of death threats from right-wing Israelis, led by Itamar Ben-Gvir, who today is a key figure in the country’s far-right coalition pushing a contentious series of judicial reforms into law.
At the time, Ben-Gvir wasn’t accepted in mainstream Israeli politics. He was an anti-Arab provocateur and the protege of extremist Rabbi Meir Kahane, who advocated for racist policies. The 21-year-old was also an outspoken admirer of Baruch Goldstein, the American-born physician who had murdered 29 Palestinians in Hebron three years prior.
Ben-Gvir and his cohort, who believed Israel should give no land to the Palestinians, opposed O’Connor’s concert – part of a festival called “Sharing Jerusalem: two capitals for two states” to be performed in the aftermath of the Oslo Accords – for its promotion of coexistence. And he insulted the singer in colourful, vulgar terms on Israeli radio.
O’Connor, he said, was a “singer who preaches and calls for the division of Jerusalem and who spreads gentile culture”, adding that she “has no place in Israel”. Though Ben-Gvir denied issuing the death threats, he viewed his group’s pressure campaign on the singer as successful after she pulled out of the festival.
Also opposing the festival was then-Jerusalem mayor Ehud Olmert, who would later go on to become Israel’s prime minister from 2006 to 2009. Olmert called it a “provocation”, and suggested that the concert had actually been cancelled due to poor ticket sales, according to a Jewish Telegraphic Agency report at the time.
O’Connor later went after Ben-Gvir directly in an open letter. “G-d doesn’t reward those who bring terror to the children of the world,” she wrote. “So you have succeeded in nothing but your soul’s failure.” Supporters of hers in Israel also took to the streets to back her over Ben-Gvir.
Fifteen years later, O’Connor was again conflicted over a scheduled performance in Israel after learning that pro-Palestinian activists were pressuring her and other artists to boycott the country. But she criticised both sides of the debate, noting that she was the sole breadwinner for her family and had a responsibility to support them.
“I don’t appreciate being bullied by anyone on either side of this debate any more than I appreciate not being properly informed by my booking agent of the potential ramifications of accepting work in war zones,” she wrote in a statement on her website that she later deleted.
After her death, Ben-Gvir’s office denied this week he had ever threatened her, and said he would remember her “favourably because of the difficult life she lived”.
O’Connor, whose biggest hit was her 1990 cover of Prince’s Nothing Compares 2 U, struggled with mental-health issues throughout her life. After speaking out against abuse in the Catholic Church, she later converted to Islam.