OpEds

Too much analysis just a hit job on Israel

Published

on

Political analysis is like a candle – in the hand of a drunk, it is downright dangerous. As the Russian fabulist Ivan Krylov, wrote in The Two Peasants, “Things go ill with a drunken man, when he has a candle in his hand; but he is even worse off when he is in the dark.” 

Much of the political commentary about the US midterm elections is casting too feeble a light to understand what really happened and how the future is likely to unfold. Most of it is only a hit job aimed at the State of Israel. 

In the cold light of day, the mischievous claim that the war with Iran and America’s relationship with Israel explain the Republican defeat, overlooks both the history of midterms, specifically that the president’s party takes a beating, and what voters said about their own finances in the past election. 

Since the Civil War midterm of 1862, only 12 of the 30 US presidents have seen their party retain control of both chambers of Congress at a midterm. Since 1934, only three presidents’ parties have gained House seats at a midterm. They were Franklin D Roosevelt’s, Bill Clinton’s and George W Bush’s. Barack Obama’s 2010 midterm ranks sixth among the largest combined seat losses since 1862. Lyndon B Johnson, who signed the landmark Civil Rights Act of 1964, saw his party lose seats in both chambers in 1966, though it kept both majorities. 

These amnesiac pundits forget that President Donald Trump’s Republicans lost the House in 2018. Trump lost the presidency in 2020 and returned to the White House after the 2024 election. He campaigned on inflation under Joe Biden, and now his own party has felt the force of the same issue. The 2026 exit polls showed that voters who said their finances had worsened backed Democrats for the House. Clinton’s chief strategist, James Carville, put it best in 1992, “The economy, stupid.” If you want to understand why Republicans lost, start with what Americans were paying at the till. 

The Middle East needs new ideas, and people across the region deserve the opportunity to change their governments, which is something we know about and cherish here in South Africa. Israel is often held to an impossibly high standard, like a wrestler expected to wear a white suit to a mud-wrestling match and docked a point for every splash. For all the difficulties Americans and Israelis face, they can vote their governments out. Iranians can vote for a president, but the Guardian Council vets who is allowed to stand. Would the ayatollahs allow an Iranian candidate to campaign on “Give peace a chance!”? One who says, “Peace with America! Peace with Israel! Love to the world!”? 

Could a candidate even run on “Make Iran Great Again” instead of spewing hatred and calling for the death of peoples around the world? 

The Palestinian legislative election scheduled for this month is set to be postponed, possibly until September 2027. Palestinians last elected their legislature more than 20 years ago, in January 2006. President Mahmoud Abbas, who was elected in January 2005, has been in office for more than 21 years. He has served roughly two years longer than Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has served as prime minister across his three terms. There is a saying that a society grows great when old men plant trees in whose shade they know they shall never sit. What tree has Abbas planted in his 21 years? Is anyone asking him? 

In his memoir, Interventions: A Life in War and Peace, the late United Nations (UN) secretary-general and Nobel Peace Prize laureate Kofi Annan wrote, “Many may have felt satisfaction in the decades of endless passing of General Assembly resolutions condemning Israel’s behaviour, I said, but what tangible relief or benefit had this brought the Palestinians? What effect had these had on Israel’s policies, other than to strengthen the belief in Israel that the UN is too one-sided to be allowed a significant role in the Middle East peace process?” Annan’s views matter enormously. During his tenure as UN secretary-general, worldwide deaths in state-based conflicts averaged about 36 125 a year, 72.2% below the 1946–2025 average of 129 854. 

Annan’s uncomfortable question still stands. What has all this noise done to bring peace any closer? 

  • Muzi Kuzwayo is the chairperson of South Africa’s Promise, a non-profit company that works with young people across the country to help them unleash their potential. 

Leave a Reply

Comments received without a full name will not be considered.
Email addresses are not published. All comments are moderated. The SA Jewish Report will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published.

Trending

Exit mobile version