OpEds

When power becomes predatory

Published

on

The conviction of British comedian Russell Brand for sexual offences, alongside the allegations against comedian-actor David Walliams, have brought an uncomfortable issue into public focus: the potential abuse of power by influential individuals. 

While these are distinct cases with different legal circumstances, they raise questions extending far beyond celebrity culture. 

How do we protect young people from exploitation? Why do vulnerable individuals sometimes struggle to recognise or resist inappropriate behaviour? And how do we ensure that innocent people, particularly adolescent boys and young men, are not psychologically destroyed by false accusations? 

These questions demand compassion, psychological understanding, and a commitment to justice. 

Predatory behaviour doesn’t always begin with obvious aggression. It may begin with charm, flattery, attention, and the intoxicating experience of being singled out by someone admired. For a young person seeking validation, recognition, or professional opportunity, attention from a powerful individual can feel extraordinarily significant. 

This is where psychological vulnerability intersects with unequal power. 

Grooming may involve gradually testing boundaries, creating emotional dependency, encouraging secrecy, and normalising increasingly inappropriate behaviour. 

A young person may experience conflicting emotions: admiration, excitement, discomfort, fear, and guilt. 

The imbalance of power can make refusal particularly difficult when someone believes their future, reputation, or opportunities depend on pleasing an influential individual. 

We must stop asking only “Why didn’t they say no?” and begin asking, “What made saying no feel so difficult?” 

Not everyone responds to threat by fighting or fleeing. Some freeze. Others appease, becoming compliant in an attempt to minimise perceived danger. These survival responses are frequently misunderstood, particularly when individuals subsequently question why they didn’t resist. 

Delayed disclosure doesn’t automatically undermine credibility. Fear of retaliation, humiliation, disbelief, and reputational damage may prevent disclosure for years. 

For some survivors, the deepest psychological injury isn’t limited to the experience itself but involves the destruction of their belief that they are safe, autonomous, and worthy of protection. 

Although the Brand and Walliams controversies originate in Britain, the underlying power dynamics are equally relevant to South Africa. Our schools, universities, sporting institutions, entertainment industry, and workplaces aren’t immune to exploitation. 

Consider the schoolgirl intimidated by an influential educator, the university student dependent on a lecturer’s approval, or the young employee frightened of losing her job. In each situation, authority can become a weapon. 

South Africa has safeguarding policies and legal frameworks, but policies alone cannot guarantee psychological safety. We need independent reporting mechanisms, transparent investigations, and institutions willing to challenge influential individuals rather than protect their reputations. 

We must also confront cultural attitudes that encourage unquestioning obedience to authority. Respect for authority should never require surrendering personal boundaries. 

Psychological education must begin early. 

Young people need to recognise warning signs such as inappropriate sexual comments, secrecy, unwanted touching, gifts accompanied by expectations, isolation from trusted relationships, and threats disguised as humour. They must understand that admiration doesn’t create obligation and that professional opportunities should never depend on sexual compliance. 

We should encourage young people to trust their discomfort, seek support, and report concerning behaviour. 

However, responsibility must never rest solely on potential victims. 

Adults, institutions, and those holding positions of authority have a fundamental responsibility to maintain appropriate boundaries and prevent exploitation. 

There is another uncomfortable reality that deserves serious consideration. False accusations of sexual misconduct can have devastating consequences, particularly for adolescent boys and young men. 

An allegation can destroy friendships, educational opportunities, reputations, and emotional stability. 

In today’s digital environment, accusations can spread through social media long before any investigation takes place. Even when allegations are disproved, reputational damage may persist. 

The psychological consequences can include humiliation, isolation, anxiety, depression, and, in severe cases, suicidal thinking. For adolescents whose identities and emotional resilience are still developing, being publicly labelled a sexual predator can be profoundly damaging. 

However, we must distinguish between deliberately fabricated accusations, misunderstandings, unsubstantiated allegations, and cases where evidence is insufficient to secure a conviction. 

These are not interchangeable. 

Research indicates that deliberately false reports constitute a minority of sexual assault allegations. Nevertheless, their consequences deserve serious attention. 

We cannot advocate psychological protection for one group while dismissing the suffering of another. 

Social media has created a disturbing phenomenon: public judgement preceding evidence. Complainants may face vicious harassment and disbelief. Equally, accused individuals may be publicly condemned before receiving a fair hearing. Both experiences can cause lasting psychological harm. 

The principle of believing victims should mean listening respectfully, taking disclosures seriously, and providing appropriate support. It shouldn’t mean abandoning independent investigation or the presumption of innocence. 

Similarly, defending due process must never become an excuse to intimidate, humiliate, or silence complainants. 

Compassion and critical thinking aren’t mutually exclusive. We can support someone who reports abuse without automatically determining guilt. We can protect the rights of the accused without dismissing the possibility that serious harm occurred. 

Perhaps our greatest preventative opportunity lies in how we raise young people. 

Girls need to understand autonomy, boundaries, and their right to refuse unwanted attention. Boys need equally meaningful education about consent, emotional responsibility, respectful relationships, and their own vulnerability to exploitation. 

Both need to recognise manipulation, understand the consequences of coercion, and appreciate the seriousness of making dishonest accusations. 

We must move beyond teaching girls to fear men and boys to fear allegations. Instead, we should cultivate mutual respect, emotional literacy, accountability, and the confidence to seek help. 

The controversies involving powerful public figures invite us to examine not only individual behaviour but also the systems that allow authority to go unquestioned. 

We must protect those who disclose abuse without automatically declaring every accused person guilty. 

We must hold perpetrators accountable without turning allegations into public entertainment. 

And we must recognise that survivors of exploitation and individuals who have been falsely accused can both experience profound psychological injuries. 

Ultimately, protecting young people requires a culture where authority can be questioned, boundaries are respected, allegations are investigated fairly, and psychological support is available to everyone affected. 

A society that fails to protect victims is unjust. A society that abandons the presumption of innocence is equally dangerous. 

Our responsibility is not to choose between these principles, but to uphold both. 

  • Dr Robyn Rosin is a counselling psychologist with extensive experience in private practice, specialising in trauma, psychological well-being, and the treatment of emotional distress.

Leave a Reply

Comments received without a full name will not be considered.
Email addresses are not published. All comments are moderated. The SA Jewish Report will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published.

Trending

Exit mobile version