Subscribe to our Newsletter


click to dowload our latest edition

J’salem in for huge snow in coming days

Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat is scheduled to visit the Municipal Centre for Snow Preparedness at 2pm Israel time today. The mayor will also inspect snow ploughs and salt throwers at the Municipal Maintenance Centre at Givat Shaul (adjacent to the Herzog Hospital). The visit coincides with weather warnings of huge snowstorms on the way and residents are being advised to stay indoors and warm. SEE LAST WINTER’S TOP-READ live-blog & pics as it was happening…

Published

on

Israel

ANT KATZ

Among Jewish Report’s most read stories last December was “Massive snowstorm shut Jerusalem down last week” which warned as follows: Police warn residents to stay indoors; Tel Aviv’s Ayalon Highway closed; a man died after falling off a roof while trying to repair a leak; thousands in Jerusalem were left without power; and Israel opened the Gaza crossing to allow entry of gas, water pumps and other essential goods. 

SAJR Top Reads 2014 - SMALLJewish Report Online published a live blog from Haaretz and just kept feeding back information to our Israeli and other readers. The 23 December 2013 rolling story, below, was supplemented by regular incoming STUNNING PICTURES from Zionist activist LEON REICH – who was (trying to) visit Israel at the time. This was super real-time live blog reporting and, not unexpectedly, found itself among the year’s top reads.

See more of Jewish Report’s “2014 Top Reads” series below…



23 December 2013:

Massive snowstorm shut J’salem down last week

LIVE BLOG by Eli Ashkenazi, Yaniv Kubovich, Nir Hasson and HAARETZ

PICTURES provided by Leon Reich 

Heavy storms continued throughout Israel on Friday, causing traffic disruptions and power outages across the country, floods in southern regions, a brief closure of Ben-Gurion International Airport, and a measure of excitement among the nation’s many snow-lovers.

Thousands of people in and around Jerusalem were left without power. A hastily assembled array of relief services, beefed up by Israeli army troops, came to the aid of hundreds of motorists who were trapped in their vehicles, some for up to 10 hours.

Snow6Speaking on the radio, Jerusalem mayor Nir Barkat described the snowstorm as a “tsunami,” for which the municipality was unprepared. The city set up several improvised snow-havens, granting shelter to hundreds of the snowed-in masses, many of whom had come to the capital to celebrate what is usually a much less torrid event.

NOTE: LIVE BLOG runs in reverse – i,e from bottom to top:

00:48 A.M.: Israel Electric Company says it has reconnected most of Jerusalem homes back to the power grid. Announces 94.5 percent of Jerusalem residents have electricity. 13,000 household still without power.

 

00:38 A.M.: The Israeli Football Association announced that two premier league soccer matches scheduled for Saturday – Bnei Sakhnin v. Beitar Jerusalem and Hapoel Ironi Kiryat Shmona v. Bnei Yehuda Tel Aviv – are postponed. The association will hold another consultation Saturday morning to decide regarding the other games scheduled for that day. The date the postponed matches are to be held has yet to be decided.

 Snow7

11:07 P.M.: Tel Aviv’s Ayalon Highway reopens after brief closure.

 

10:35 P.M.: Some 50,000 households – mostly in Jerusalem and the settlements – still don’t have power. 

 

9:50 P.M.: Tel Aviv’s Ayalon Highway closes to traffic due to flooding of Ayalon River.

 

9:01 P.M.: Storm in Safed intensifies; snow levels reach almost 2 feet.

 

8:50 P.M.: Israel Police say Tel Aviv’s Ayalon Highway to close within an hour due to floods.

 Snow5

8:20 P.M.: Israel Railways to operate two free trains on Saturday from Jerusalem to Tel Aviv and Haifa. First train due to depart at 11 A.M. and the second at 2 P.M. 

 

7:10 P.M.: Rishon Letzion man dies after falling off the roof of his house while attempting to repair a leak caused by the storm.

 

6:15 P.M.: Snowfall reported in the southern city of Dimona.

 

6:10 P.M.: All roads leading to the Golan Heights and the city of Safed closed for traffic.

 

 5:50 P.M.: Israel Electric Corp says power restored to about half of the residents of Jerusalem and surrounding neighborhoods.

 

4:45 P.M. Economy Minister Naftali Bennett instructs his ministry to approve all requests to employ workers over Shabbat in order to allow for rescue and repair operations in light of the storm.

 Snow4

4:25 P.M. Snowfall resumes in Jerusalem and is expected to continue until early Saturday morning. Israel Police and the Jerusalem municipality instruct residents to stay indoors.

 

4:20 P.M. Residents report landslide in East Jerusalem neighborhood of Silwan, which they say endangers the foundations of three residential buildings that have already begun to crack. According to residents, the municipality recently conducted renovations in the area, but saved money by not building a supporting wall. This wall, they said, could have prevented the landslide.

 

4:10 P.M. After holding a meeting with Jerusalem Mayor Nir Barkat, Public Security Minister Yitzhak Aharonovitch, security services and emergency rescue services, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says, “We are prepared in case the weather continues and I request all citizens listen to the instructions of the authorities.”

 Snow1

“From snowy Jerusalem, I wish everyone a peaceful Sabbath, especially to the police and soldiers, Magen David Adom https://www.sajr.co.za/images/default-source/places/snow.jpg” />

1:38 P.M.: The kibbutz movement and the Mate Yehuda regional council are considering the evacuation of thier residents who were cut off from electricity. In case such a decision is made, kibbutzim and moshavim in central Israel will host the evacuees.

 

1:30 P.M.: Route 1 between Jerusalem and Tel Aviv is still closed to traffic, as is a portion of route 6 and sections of Ayalon highway.

 

11:46: A.M.: Public Security Minister says it will take days to repair the damage caused by the storm. All in all some 2,400 people were aided by relief services.

 

11:20 A.M.: Seeking to evaluate the storm’s impact on cities in the West Bank, the IDF has contacted Palestinian Authority representatives. According to an IDF officer, the storm is creating similar problems in the PA territories-  but that at the present time, no aid is being given to the West Bank’s Palestinian population. “But if we will need to – we will help there, too,” he added.

 

11:03 A.M.: Evacuation of all drivers trapped in route 443 completed. Security Ministry aid convoys making their way towards Mevaseret Zion and Beit Horon area. Snow is accumulating on the peaks of Jordan’s Edom Mountains, near Eilat.

 Snow3

10:38 A.M.: Air traffic to and from Israel was shut off for some 40 minutes due to thick clouds over Ben Gurion Airport. Two commercial aircraft that were en route to Israel were diverted to Larnaca in Cyprus for landing, and will be flying to Israel shotrly.

 

10:08 A.M.: Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu spoke with Public Security Minister Yitzhak Aharonovitch and Israel Police Commissioner Yohanan Danino on Friday morning, and received updates regarding police and army efforts to rescue drivers stuck in their vehicles on roads throughout Israel.

 

Defence Minister Moshe Ya’alon also notified the prime minister that the IDF will continue assisting civilian rescue services for as long as necessary.

 

9:16 A.M.: Residents in almost all of Jerusalem’s neighbourhoods have reported blackouts, most of which have been caused by trees collapsing on power lines due to the snow. The problem is most prevalent in the city’s older neighbourhoods, which have larger trees and more outdated power infrastructure. There have been widespread power outages reported in Kiryat Yovel, Ramat Beit Hakerem, downtown Jerusalem, and Ora, a small town outside of the city.

 SnowHOME

Outages were also reported in Jerusalem’s suburbs: Abu Ghosh, Neve Ilan, Tzur Hadassah, Mevo Beitar, Givat Ze’ev, Givon, Beit Zayit, Gush Etzion, Beit El, Bar Giora, Hes Harim, Ma’ale Hahamisha, Tzuba, as well as settlements in Samaria and the South Hebron Hills.

 

9:01 A.M.: MK Ariel Attias was one of the thousands of individuals stuck on the roads to Jerusalem last night. Attias was stuck in his vehicle for 12 hours, and was rescued at 8:00 A.M., and taken to the Ofer military base outside of Jerusalem. “This was a total failure. It’s completely unreasonable that in 2013, Israel’s capital is paralyzed,” said Attias. “Where were all of the preparations? The ploughs and the salters? There were children here, people stuck without gas. People could have frozen to death,” continued Attias.

 

According to the MK, the IDF and the Israel Police did not attempt to assist the people stuck on the roads overnight. “No one talks to you, every many for himself. There was no one to call, the police and the municipality didn’t answer. In the end, I saw an army jeep, and asked them to pull me out of the snow.”

 

8:40 A.M.: Thousands of Jerusalem residents were left without power during the night. Roughly 700 people were stuck in their cars on the roads near Jerusalem, and were rescued during the early morning. Hundreds more are still waiting for rescue.

 

8:35 A.M.: The Israel Police have called on citizens to refrain from driving. The southbound Ayalon freeway is covered in ice, and is very dangerous.

 

8:28 A.M.: Jerusalem resident Avi Levi told Haaretz that he has been stuck two kilometers from Jerusalem since Thursday evening. “Fortunately I went food shipping yesterday, so I had what to eat, but soon I’ll have to start eating raw potatoes,” he said with a smile, though like many others stuck on the roads, he was full of criticism for the police. “They should have closed the roads. Before I left I called the municipality’s call centre and they told me the roads were open,” said Levi. “When the police want to close a road, they put an officer every two meters. Not a single plough passed by here all night. Police cars that went by didn’t stop to see how the people were doing. It’s stupidity.”

 

7:41 A.M.: Snow fell in northern Israel overnight. School was cancelled in Safed, and roads leading to the city were closed. 10 centimeters of snow also fell in the northern Golan Heights, and public transportation in the area has been shut down, and school was cancelled as well.

 

Capital unprepared for storm’s severity

 

Roads to and from Jerusalem were closed Thursday night and school there was cancelled for Friday as the heaviest December storm since 1953 fell on the capital city.

 

Snow began falling in Jerusalem Thursday morning. The winter weather system, which began Tuesday night, intensified across the country.

 

Police blocked traffic on roads leading to the capital in both directions until 6 A.M. Friday, after snow fell on Highways 1 and 443. Highway 60 was also blocked in both directions between Gush Etzion and Ha’okfim Junction. The wintery weather is expected to continue today, and schools will be closed in Jerusalem, Ofakim and Arad.



Stories in this series of Top Reads 2014:



Mount Hermon saw more snow Thursday, totaling 60 centimeters since Tuesday. Snow also pelted the northern city of Safed Thursday evening. Dozens of millimeters of rain have fallen in the greater Tel Aviv region, the Sharon and the Galilee since Wednesday night.

 

Schools in the capital and its environs were closed Thursday, as well as in Rahat, Umm al-Fahm, the regional councils of Ma’ale Iron, Neve Midbar and Al Kasum, and in Ofra, Psagot and Beit El. The Education Ministry has called upon parents to stay updated via the municipal hotline in their locality, by calling the school itself, or on the ministry’s Facebook page.

 

There were several weather-related incidents. In southern Israel. A car with nine children was swept away by a flood in the Garar River area Thursday. They were evacuated with the driver and airlifted to Soroka Medical Center in Be’er Sheva suffering light injuries from exposure. Ofakim’s water main exploded due to floods, leaving the southern town without tap water. A 45-year-old man was evacuated to Assaf Harofeh Hospital in Tzrifin in moderate condition with hypothermia, after he was found lying on a street in the city of Lod.

 

The cold snap was forecast to continue Friday. As of Thursday night, Friday’s forecast was rain and cold, with snow on the summits of the mountains in the north and centre, and possibly on the summits of the southern hills as well. The rain will continue Saturday, when snow is expected to continue falling in the mountains. It will still be colder than usual. On Sunday the weather will be partly cloudy with a slight rise in temperatures. There is still a possibility of light local rain, and a possibility of frost at night.

 

Dr Amos Porat of the Meteorological Service said, “At the moment we’re only in the initial stage of the present system.” Porat describes the anticipated system as one without a short beginning, middle and end: “It will enter gradually with cold air, rain and snow, with stronger and weaker waves. On Shabbat the system will decline gradually.”

 

The Meteorological Service reported that since the beginning of the storm two days ago and up to Thursday afternoon, the largest amounts of rain, 40-60 mm., were measured in the southern Coastal Plain, the central mountain areas and the Sharon. The north and the centre received 20-40 mm. and in the south there was almost no rain. In Kibbutz Negba, near Kiryat Malakhi, 55 mm. of rain fell in the past 24 hours, in Jerusalem 51 mm. and in Tel Aviv 41 mm.

 

The community of Harashim in the Galilee had 52 mm, Nahariya 41 mm. and Haifa only 14 mm.

 

  • Eli Ashkenazi, Yaniv Kubovich, Jack Khoury, Yarden Skop, Shirly Seidler, Zohar Blumenkrantz and Nir Hasson contributed to this report.


Stories in this series of Top Reads 2014:


Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Israel

SA seethes as Israel scores diplomatic coup in AU

Published

on

The South African government this week lashed out at the recent decision by the African Union (AU) to grant Israel observer status.

After nearly 20 years of persistent diplomatic efforts, Israel last week attained observer status at the AU. The development was welcomed by Israel, who has long held that the Jewish state has much to offer Africa.

However, predictably, it has been shunned by the government and local pro-Palestinian groups.

In a statement on 28 July, the Department of International Relations and Cooperation (DIRCO), said it was “appalled” at the decision calling it “unjust” and “unwarranted”.

It said that in the context of the recent flare-up of violence in the Middle East, the decision was “inexplicable”, and accused the AU Commission of taking the decision unilaterally without consulting its members.

DIRCO said it would ask the chairperson of the commission to provide a briefing to all member states, which it hoped would be further discussed.

“South Africa firmly believes that as long as Israel isn’t willing to negotiate a peace plan without preconditions, it shouldn’t have observer status,” the statement said.

Earlier this week, the SA BDS coalition slammed the government for its silence on the matter, and for not immediately criticising the move like it has done in the past. The organisation urged the government, as well as other AU member states, to reject Israel’s claim to accreditation.

“We are extremely disappointed that our government didn’t immediately publicly reject the Israeli claim and announce that it would lodge an objection to the AU chair,” it said.

The SA BDS coalition accused Israel of “falsely claiming” that its assistance to African states in fields such as agriculture, technology, and economic development was philanthropic.

“In reality, this is simply opportunistic leverage,” it said, adding that Israel’s objective was to “muscle recipient states” to support it at the United Nations (UN) and other international fora.

One local pro-Palestinian media organisation tweeted “Remove the Zionist cancer from the AU”.

South Africa, along with several other African nations, has long opposed Israel’s desire to gain observer status at the 55-member continental organisation. While chairing the AU Commission from 2012 to 2017, Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma strongly objected to Israel’s rapprochement with the organisation.

In November last year on the UN International Day of Solidarity with the Palestinian People, DIRCO Deputy Minister Alvin Botes accused Israel of “vociferously” lobbying African states to support its bid, saying that it was “more important than ever” to ensure that this didn’t happen.

Said Botes, “There is a growing and justifiable sense that certain African and Arab nations no longer see the liberation of Palestine as a common objective.”

He said Israel, with the support of America, was driving a wedge between these nations. “If Israel continues to score political victories while facing little resistance, it could eventually dominate Africa,” Botes said.

Algeria on Sunday condemned the decision of the AU to grant Israel observer status.

Israel previously held observer status at the Organisation of African Unity (OAU), but has long been thwarted in its attempts to get it back after the OAU was disbanded in 2002 and replaced by the AU.

Former Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu prioritised Israel’s relations with Africa during the latter half of his 12 years in office, including with several Muslim-majority countries on the continent.

Besides seeking new markets for Israeli expertise in fields like agriculture, high-tech, and security, Netanyahu was keen to improve African nations’ voting record on Israel-related matters in international fora such as the UN Security Council.

Aleligne Admasu, the Israeli ambassador to Ethiopia, Burundi, and Chad, on 22 July presented his credentials to Moussa Faki Mahamat, the chairperson of the AU Commission, at the bloc’s headquarters in the Ethiopian capital, Addis Ababa.

Israeli Foreign Minister Yair Lapid hailed it as a “day of celebration for Israel-Africa relations”, noting that Israel currently has relations with 46 African countries.

The move will enable stronger co-operation between the two parties on various aspects, including the fight against coronavirus and the prevention “of the spread of extremist terrorism” on the African continent, the statement said.

In a separate statement, Faki Mahamat stressed the AU’s position over the longstanding Israeli-Palestinian conflict, reiterating the bloc’s stance that a two-state solution was “necessary for peaceful co-existence”.

Steven Gruzd, the head of the African Governance and Diplomacy Programme at the South African Institute of International Affairs said it was a pragmatic decision by the AU rather than an ideological one, as “Israel has a lot to offer Africa”.

“South Africa will feel a little out-manoeuvred on this one, given that during Dlamini-Zuma’s tenure as AU commissioner, the proposal was blocked presumably by Arab states in the North of Africa as well as countries like South Africa.

“This seems to be a diplomatic coup for the Israelis. It has been quite a long time coming, and even though symbolic in many ways, it’s an entry into a forum where their interests are being discussed, and it will provide a platform for a deeper engagement with the continent.”

Since 2016, Netanyahu has been to Africa five times, displaying Israel’s keen interest in growing relations with African states, Gruzd said.

“Also, as part of the Abraham Accords process, we’ve seen normalisation with Morocco and Sudan, both Muslim-majority states. So, Israel’s forays into Africa is paying dividends, and I think it will be very pleased about this. South Africa is a strong supporter of the Palestinians, and I guess will see this as a defeat, but it’s not like pressure on Israel is going to be reduced by South Africa.”

Rowan Polovin, the national chairperson of the South African Zionist Federation (SAZF), welcomed the development, saying it was hopeful that AU members would work more closely with Israel on issues such as fighting the coronavirus, improving regional security, and implementing water, agricultural, and healthcare technology solutions.

“We are also further encouraged that the AU status may assist other African countries to do the same,” Polovin said.

“The SAZF believes that greater intercontinental co-operation with Israel is a sign that the South African government should follow suit in building and improving its relations with Israel. Furthering the partnership with Israel would bring increased positive benefits and impacts for all South Africans, and would help address the triple challenges of poverty, unemployment, and inequality.”

Israel re-established relations with Guinea in 2016 and Chad in 2019. In October 2020, Israel also signed a normalisation agreement with Sudan.

In July 2016, Netanyahu became the first Israeli premier in decades to travel to the continent when he visited Uganda, Kenya, Rwanda, and Ethiopia. There has been ongoing collaboration and engagement ever since with a number of African countries.

Meanwhile, the first direct commercial flights between Israel and Morocco landed in Marrakesh on Sunday, 25 July, more than seven months after the countries normalised diplomatic relations in a United States-brokered deal. This is another example of Israel and Africa moving closer together.

Passengers from Tel Aviv arrived on an Israir flight early on Sunday afternoon, and were met with dates, cakes, and mint tea at a welcoming ceremony organised in their honour. A second flight, by Israeli national carrier El Al, landed in Marrakesh later in the day. Both airlines are planning several flights per week to Marrakesh and Casablanca.

Morocco was one of four regional states to agree to normalise ties with Israel last year, along with the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, and Sudan.

The normalisation deals between Arab states and Israel have been deemed a “betrayal” by the Palestinians, who believe the process should follow resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Continue Reading

Israel

Aliyah interest spikes after unrest

Published

on

The director of the Israel Centre South Africa, Liat Amar Arran, says the organisation received “100 enquiries” into aliyah over the past three weeks, and that “at least 50 files were opened” – the first step in the aliyah process.

Comparing these figures to the 30 to 40 enquiries the organisation normally gets every month, Amar Arran says although she’s happy South African Jews see Israel as an option, we shouldn’t make aliyah in a panic.

“Making aliyah in an emergency means the person isn’t ready and hasn’t had time to do their research. It means they’re running away, and it’s very hard to settle when you are running away from something. Aliyah is a process.” Amar Arran emphasises that while Israel will always be there for South African Jews, it’s unlikely it would ever evacuate the community unless lives were truly at stake.

She says the Israeli government was updated during the unrest, but didn’t see it as an evacuation-type situation. Her team and the Israeli government have faith that the Jewish community will stay and succeed in South Africa for decades to come. “Israel will be there to strengthen, support, and assist,” she says.

She points out that Israel isn’t a solution to the complex challenges that people might be facing in South Africa. “If you are struggling financially, Israel isn’t going to save you. Yes, it gives some support and assistance, but aliyah doesn’t mean all your problems are going to be solved. You will probably carry the same problems with you. We want to see olim succeed, not collapse. You may get some assistance in the beginning, but eventually, you need to live your life there. We don’t want you to look back and say, ‘Why did I make this decision?’”

If you want to have the option of aliyah in a time of emergency, “then open a file now, and work on it [getting documents]. Don’t wait. You want to be ready on your side. Then you know that you have the documents, even if you might never use them. That’s your insurance.”

She emphasises that the Israel Centre doesn’t have the capacity to “hold people’s hand”, and that it’s each individual’s responsibility to gather their documents and do their research. While she and her team offer guidance, advice, and support, each person has to take their own steps.

She refers to the joke of a man in a town that’s flooding, and people keep offering him help – in a car, a boat, and a helicopter, but he refuses to go with them because he’s “waiting”. Eventually, he drowns and goes to heaven, where he asks G-d, “Why didn’t you come save me?” And G-d answers, “I sent you a car, a boat, and a helicopter!”

Essentially, she’s saying that you can take practical steps like opening an aliyah file if you want to have an option during times of crisis. You can also watch the informative video explaining the aliyah process that the Israel Centre recently released online. There will also be an aliyah Q&A webinar on 5 August, and the Israel Centre hosts these webinars often for prospective olim.

Though the organisation has been stretched to capacity in recent weeks, Amar Arran doesn’t expect the high level of interest to continue unless there’s more unrest. In addition, she says there is always more aliyah interest during harder lockdowns, when people are at home, less busy, and thinking about the future.

Meanwhile, olim who are making aliyah this week say the process takes time. “Getting all my South African documents [to make aliyah] was the biggest challenge, especially during COVID-19,” says Tammy Wainer. “At times it felt like I was climbing up a mountain with no end in sight! Once I had all my South African documents, it was smooth sailing.”

To others considering aliyah, she says: “Aliyah is a very big decision. Do your research, and weigh the pros and cons. Israel will be there waiting with open arms, but ultimately, it will be up to you to make a new life for yourself.”

The recent unrest in South Africa didn’t have an impact on her decision, but “it made it easier for me to say goodbye. I won’t miss going to bed at night feeling anxious at the sound of gun shots. But at the same time, it makes me worried about the loved ones I leave behind. Just because we are leaving South Africa, doesn’t mean we are turning our back on South Africa. The fire of South Africa lives in all of us, and I will continue to be proudly South African and proud of our incredible Jewish community from afar.”

Tamar Lutrin is in Grade 10, and making aliyah with her family. “Making aliyah during COVID-19 was both beneficial and hard. It was easier to leave because we weren’t spending every second with the people we love, but at the same time, we couldn’t say proper goodbyes.” To others considering making the move, she says, “Don’t prolong it, go as soon as you can. It’s hard to break down a life here without building up a new one there.”

The recent unrest “made it easier to leave”, Lutrin says. “My family and I were never leaving South Africa because we hated it, we love South Africa and the community, but it did make the grass look greener on the other side.”

Says Sandra (Sandi) Shapiro, “After the current unrest in South Africa, I can say that I’m fortunate to be one of the lucky ones to be able to leave South Africa in such uncertain times. I leave behind family and friends, and I worry for them all. I can only pray that Hashem will protect all of South Africa, and that peace, harmony, and tranquillity will prevail.”

Continue Reading

Israel

Commonwealth Jewish Council calls for release of ‘Nigeria three’

Published

on

All Rudy Rochman wanted to do was to shine a light on unknown, disconnected, and re-emerging Jewish communities around the world, but something went horribly wrong.

The charismatic 27-year-old Israeli activist, who has more than 97 000 followers on Instagram, was working on a new documentary series titled, We Were Never Lost, which focused on these “lost tribes”. At the beginning of July, he and his team travelled to Nigeria to film their first episode.

However, Rochman, filmmaker Andrew Noam Leibman, and French-Israeli journalist Edouard David Benaym were arrested by Nigerian security services when the three presented a Torah scroll to a local community. They remain in custody, haven’t been charged, and haven’t been given legal representation. Organisations and individuals around the world are working desperately to get them released.

“Our first season is set in Africa, and we are filming our first episode on the Jews of Nigeria,” Rochman’s team wrote on Facebook on 8 July. “There are many Jews in Nigeria, Igbos included, and we are here only to help local practising and observing Jewish communities, to provide them with resources, and to document their lives, experiences, and aspirations. We don’t take any position on political movements as we aren’t here as politicians nor as a part of any government delegation.”

But the next day, they were arrested, supposedly for supporting “separatist activists”. Commonwealth Jewish Council (CJC) Chief Executive Clive Lawton is one of the many people working behind the scenes. Speaking to the SA Jewish Report from his home in the United Kingdom, he says he is alarmed that the men have been held in detention for more than a week without being charged. “That would indicate it’s only an investigation, but they still have no legal representation, and how can such an investigation take more than a week?”

He says the CJC has written to the Nigerian high commissioner to the Commonwealth, His Excellency Sarafa Tunji Isola, urging him to pressure his government to release them soon. “They are being detained on the flimsiest of pretexts. I’m sure the Nigerian government wouldn’t want to cultivate an image that foreign visitors can be snatched up on spurious accusations,” says Lawton.

He has also written to the secretary general of the Commonwealth of Nations, Baroness Patricia Scotland. “In this family of nations, the quality of relationships and expectations of decency carry a lot of weight. It’s shocking that Nigeria might continue to hobnob with other heads of governments while treating foreigners like this. It should be seen as shameful. Yes, they might need to investigate something, but that doesn’t take 10 days. This isn’t just an investigation. It’s intimidation. Acting without due process is against Commonwealth principles,” he says.

He hopes that the less formal relationships between Commonwealth countries will make an impact. “At the very least, they should be released to go home. But more desirable would be that they be allowed to return to their cultural activity of making a documentary.”

Lawton says his organisation seeks to build relationships between Jews from around the world. More than 40 countries, including South Africa, are members.

Although the media reported that “three Israelis” were arrested, it’s unclear if all three have Israeli citizenship.

Lawton says Rochman and Leibman entered Nigeria on their American passports, and Benaym on his French passport. “We knew that they planned to make this documentary and were in the first stages of filming. They went to south-east Nigeria to visit a community. Like anyone making such a visit, they wanted to bring artefacts or objects to present to them. In this instance, they very generously brought a Sefer Torah.”

Two weeks ago, Rochman wrote on Instagram about how his team had “just acquired a beautiful Torah that survived the Holocaust and is believed to have come from an old community in Ukraine about 200 years ago”.

“The scribal experts our team spoke to stated that the ktav [writing] had since gone extinct, and they couldn’t believe their eyes when we sent them pictures of the scroll.

“We will be bringing the Torah and gifting it to the youth movement of Igbo Jewish communities of Nigeria for them to have access to our nation’s holy text.”

“It would seem that some separatist activists wrote Facebook messages along the lines of ‘welcoming this act of solidarity’”, Lawton says. “But in fact the filmmakers categorically stated that they had no interest in political issues and were there for a cultural reason – to make a film.

“They arrived on a Thursday, and visited a synagogue,” he says. “That was when Nigerian security services entered the synagogue and arrested them, taking them to the capital, Abuja. On the Friday, the men’s embassies were alerted, and sought to get involved. Chabad in Abuja has managed to organise provision of kosher food for them, which the security services agreed to allow. They also agreed for Benaym to be transported to the French embassy for medical attention, as long as he was returned to detention, and that is what was done. Israel has no ‘formal locus’ to help as they didn’t enter on Israeli passports, but it has sought to engage government and services.”

He believes that they are being held in some kind of “detention circumstances”, but cannot say what these conditions are like, if they are separated, or if they are being held with others. But he says that the fact that the French embassy was willing to return Benaym suggests it was “probably not extreme”.

A member of the Igbo community, speaking to the SA Jewish Report on condition of anonymity, says, “Our information is that Rudy and co. came here to do a documentary on the connection of the Igbo people to Biblical Israelites. Many Igbos are reviving the practices of their ancestors and returning to Judaism. This is what Rudy and his team wanted to do – to hear our story as told by our people. But sadly, some local people hijacked the original intention of Rudy and began to make political capital out of it. The team was bringing a Sefer Torah to be donated to our community. We were very happy that many Israelis would get to know about our Israelite heritage and know that we are brethren.

“Our people are very saddened by the arrest, but we don’t want to heighten tension by making utterances as the matter is being handled. We keep praying for their safety. We believe they will be released because their visit was for religious reasons. We don’t believe they came here to undermine the security of Nigeria. In our synagogues, we don’t entertain separatist activities. We are very sad about their plight. We see it as someone getting into unforeseen trouble while in search of a long lost brother.”

The most recent update on the We Were Never Lost Instagram page is that, “Rudy, Noam, and David are still in custody, but are ok. Their spirits remain high. Three embassies are working diligently towards a resolution. No other action is necessary from the community at this stage, but thank you all for the care and support.”

Continue Reading

HOLD Real Estate

Trending