JTA – Like many other fans heading into the 2 October New York Film Festival screening of Maestro, Alexander Gorlin was aware of the “Jewface” controversy that has plagued the film.
But acting is a “cross-cultural” exercise, said Gorlin, who is Jewish. His architectural firm has designed several Jewish houses of worship.
“If you’re talented enough to play the role, you should do so,” Gorlin told the Jewish Telegraphic Agency in the lobby outside Lincoln Center’s David Geffen Hall. “You’re not limited by your birth identity. The greatest actors are the ones who transcend that.”
Maestro, a biopic about Leonard Bernstein starring and directed by Bradley Cooper, took heat for months over its non-Jewish star’s use of a prosthetic nose. Online discourse was so intense that Bernstein’s three children issued a statement defending Cooper, saying he included them in “every step” of the production process. The makeup artist who created the prosthetic apologised for hurting people’s feelings. Even the Anti-Defamation League got involved.
But the atmosphere in the David Geffen lobby between the film’s two screenings on Monday night – which marked the film’s North American premiere – was light and celebratory. Granted, many in attendance were avowed fans of Bernstein, Cooper, and classical music. Still, most were well read on the details of the nose controversy and decidedly over it.
“I thought it was appropriate, and I have no problem. The nose seemed right for the movie,” said Scott Drevnig, who is Jewish and the deputy director of the historic Glass House in Connecticut. He spent a large chunk of the screening that he attended trying to figure out if Cooper was sitting directly in front of him (he was).
Many ticket holders were more occupied with other aspects of the film and its plot, which focuses heavily on Bernstein’s marriage to actress Felicia Montealegre. Even though the two had an understanding about Bernstein’s love life and a genuine romantic connection, their relationship strains under the weight of Bernstein’s many gay affairs and his scrutiny in the public eye.
“I grew up loving Bernstein, and it felt totally fine,” Greg Outwater, who isn’t Jewish and works in fundraising for Northwestern University, said about the prosthetic nose. “I thought it was going to be a little bit more about the music and his conducting. That’s the only thing that I wasn’t expecting.”
Sarah Silverman, who a few years ago was one of the voices who helped amplify the “Jewface” criticism of non-Jewish actors playing Jewish characters, co-stars in Maestro, as Bernstein’s sister, Shirley. Silverman hasn’t been able to comment on the film publicly due to the ongoing American actors’ union strike.
The film makes Bernstein’s Jewish identity clear early and often. At the party where Bernstein first meets Montealegre, who is played by Carey Mulligan, the two bond over having Jewish parents. Montealegre, who was born in Costa Rica and raised in Chile, had a Jewish American father.
As Bernstein’s career picks up speed, a Russian-Jewish composer tells him he’ll find much more success if he changes his name to the less Jewish-sounding “Burns”. (Montealegre convinces him that it’s bad advice.) And later in the film, Bernstein is shown wearing a sweater with Hebrew on it. The movie’s closing credits feature Jewish prayers set to classical music melodies.
Its opening credits feature some of Hollywood’s biggest names as producers, notably Steven Spielberg and Martin Scorsese. Spielberg had hand-picked Cooper to helm the project after watching A Star Is Born.
The Spielberg-Cooper bid to buy the rights to use Bernstein’s music ultimately defeated a bid by another prominent Jewish actor: Jake Gyllenhaal.
In 2021, not long after losing the bid battle, Gyllenhaal commented on the ordeal to Deadline. “That idea of playing one of the most pre-eminent Jewish artists in America and his struggle with his identity was in my heart for 20 odd years,” he said.
That storyline was more disturbing than the nose controversy for Melissa Tomczak, a 24-year-old who works at a literary agency.
“I don’t necessarily think that non-Jewish people can’t play Jewish people or make films about Jewish people,” said Tomczak, who isn’t Jewish. “But it kind of sucks that [Gyllenhaal] is someone who is a stage actor, and he admires Bernstein, and wasn’t able to make the film.”
Bernstein, who is widely considered the first great American orchestral conductor and who composed music in different genres, from classical to the Broadway style of his West Side Story, was engaged with Judaism throughout his life. In 1963, he wrote a symphony titled Kaddish, dedicated to the late John F. Kennedy. He and legendary choreographer Jerome Robbins collaborated on a ballet called Dybbuk, based on S. Ansky’s early 20th-century Yiddish play, The Dybbuk. And after Israel’s Six-Day War in 1967, Bernstein conducted a historic concert on Jerusalem’s Mount Scopus.
For Annalise Pelous, a 23-year-old film production co-ordinator at Monday night’s screenings, the Bernstein family’s embrace of Cooper’s vision went a long way. Bernstein’s elder daughter, Jamie, helped introduce the film at a podium before both screenings, saying almost breathlessly that the audience was “in for a treat”.
“The family was totally fine with it,” Pelous said about the nose backstory. “I don’t know, it’s like … whatever.”
The film as a whole seemed to split Monday’s audience. Some found it to be a masterpiece, others found it trite. Many were awed by the way the film’s soundtrack boomed through a specially designed Dolby sound system.
“It felt a little bit hollow. I feel like a lot of the things that Netflix is helping make kind of all have the same look, and I keep waiting for something to break free from that,” Pelous said of the movie. After the film debuts in theatres on 22 November, it heads to Netflix on 20 December. “But a lot of the music was incredible,” she said.
