NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIPTION


click to dowload our latest edition

CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

The Jewish Report Editorial

Jozi voted. The dealmakers aren’t listening

Avatar photo

Published

on

On 4 November, Johannesburg didn’t whisper. It spoke, and it couldn’t have been clearer. The ANC’s share of the vote collapsed from 33.6% to 20.3%, a rejection no amount of spin can soften. The DA surged from 26.1% to 34.8%, and ActionSA held at 16.3%. 

This wasn’t a protest vote. It was a decision. Residents looked at the dry taps, the broken roads, and the years of excuses, and they chose parties that promised honest administration, a city that works, and a mayor who stays long enough to fix things. 

Less than two weeks later, the bazaar has opened. There is no plan to rescue Johannesburg, only a scramble for the spoils. News reports say the ANC has offered ActionSA the mayoral positions in Johannesburg and Tshwane, plus a carve-up of mayoral committee posts. The DA, the leading party in each of these metros, has sent a proposal of its own. No deal has been signed, but the haggling is public. ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba said it bluntly on election weekend, “I’ve got the cards.” Voters didn’t hand out cards. They handed out a mandate. 

Nobody in these talks seems to be asking the question residents are asking: what happens on Monday morning when the taps are still dry? 

This is not abstract. Residents in Parktown West say they have endured up to 12 weeks without reliable water. The Centre for Development and Enterprise (CDE) reports that Johannesburg’s gross unpaid consumer bills reached R71.8 billion in 2024/25, up from R15.3 billion a decade earlier. By the end of that financial year, the city also owed suppliers, principally Eskom and Rand Water, R28.5 billion. Business leaders have described Johannesburg’s decline as a “national economic emergency”, a phrase echoed by the CDE in a release this week. 

Almost half the water Johannesburg buys from Rand Water is lost to leaks and pipe bursts. By the end of December 2025, the city had spent just 26% of its R8.7 billion capital budget. Meanwhile, the mayor has changed seven times since the 2021 election. Every change resets the clock, and every reset costs residents another season of potholes, outages, and uncollected refuse. 

Let me say plainly what I believe many of us were voting for. We voted against a political culture in which too many see the city as a source of funds rather than a public trust. We voted against tenders that enrich the connected while pipes burst, and against councillors who treat residents as an afterthought. 

Even the ANC’s secretary-general, Fikile Mbalula, called the election result “catastrophic”, and said that when the people say the party has fallen short, “the honest answer is not to argue with them but to go home and put our house in order”. If that is sincere, the party should accept the verdict, not bargain its way back into the mayoral parlour through the side door. 

The demand for accountability applies to every party at the table. A vote for clean government isn’t a blank cheque for whoever wins the most seats. It’s an instruction to anyone who would govern: show us you are different. 

There is a second betrayal unfolding and it concerns the party voters actually put first. The DA won 34.8% of the vote in Johannesburg, well ahead of the ANC on 20.3% and ActionSA on 16.3%. It campaigned openly on Helen Zille as its mayoral candidate. You may admire her or not, but Joburgers voted for a DA that told them she would be its mayor. Yet the Financial Mail reports that much of the political energy outside the DA is now being spent on finding ways to keep Zille and her party out of government. ActionSA has made her removal a condition of working with the DA. Its national chair, Michael Beaumont, says, “Our issue in Johannesburg is not the DA; it’s Helen Zille.” 

Meanwhile, there are news reports that ActionSA and the ANC are close to a deal that would hand ActionSA the mayoral chain and give the ANC the deputy mayoralty. Think about that arrangement. The party that came third gets to be mayor, the party that voters punished keeps a seat at the top table, and the party that won is left outside. 

ActionSA says its objection is about Zille’s record on coalitions, not personal animus. Perhaps. But the feud between Zille and Mashaba dates back to his 2019 resignation, from the DA and as mayor, and it is being played out in public. When a frustrated voter complained on X that Zille was being kept out of office regardless of what voters wanted, Mashaba reposted it with, “South Africa, let’s all cry for Helen. Life is not fair.” That is not the voice of a leader weighing the interests of a city whose taps are dry. 

Political analyst Theo Neethling warned that it would be “politically odd” for the DA to replace Zille simply to accommodate Mashaba’s personal objections. DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis admitted that dropping her would be “extraordinarily difficult for us to swallow”, adding that he was “not sure if it would be right for the people of Johannesburg” because “a plurality of people in Johannesburg voted for Helen”. He is right about that. It takes two to feud, and Zille has had sharp words of her own for Mashaba. Coalitions require compromise, and the DA needs partners. But compromise cannot mean that a party with less than half the DA’s support gets to veto the choice of the voters. The new council must sit by 28 November, and the clock is ticking. 

Safety is the other half of the promise. Our community knows better than most what it costs to feel safe in this city when the state falls short. Volunteers in the CSO guard our shuls, schools, and events. CAP, which began in greater Glenhazel in 2006, reports an average 84% reduction in serious violent crime in the areas it serves, and says that last year was Glenhazel’s safest since CAP’s inception. That shows prevention works when it is organised and funded. But we pay for it on top of our rates, and many living here cannot afford to do so. A city that polices its streets, fixes its streetlights, enforces its by-laws, and keeps its traffic lights working is a safer city for everyone, and safety should not be a privilege of the suburbs that can afford it. 

Residents need transparency and a mayor who is competent and has integrity. No portfolio can be given to anyone facing allegations of corruption, and we need to see a costed 100-day plan for water, electricity, roads, and safety. We also need a coalition that is built to last five years, with clear outcomes along the way. 

Johannesburg is the engine of this country’s economy and home of the most South African Jews. It has the people, the talent, and the potential to be a great city again. What it lacks is leadership that puts residents first. Voters did their part on 4 November, with more than half of Gauteng’s registered voters turning out. Now it is the politicians’ turn to do theirs. 

Rabbi Tarfon taught in Pirkei Avot that “it is not your duty to finish the work, but neither are you free to desist from it”. Our politicians haven’t even started. They should begin by listening to the people who sent them there. 

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Comments received without a full name will not be considered.
Email addresses are not published. All comments are moderated. The SA Jewish Report will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published.