Putin holds up Israel as a model of unity
(JTA) Vladimir Putin clearly likes to talk about Jews and Israel. This time, he suggested that Israel offered a good model for his designs on Ukraine.
The Russian president’s previous remarks about Jews include the joke he told at a panel on energy in 2017 about a smartass Israeli soldier who was quizzed by his commander on how to engage multiple enemies. The soldier’s advice: send more troops.
In 2019, hearing about the financial challenges of a rabbi in Crimea, Putin joked, “So the Jews have problems with finances!” Then he told the rabbi, “Todah rabah [thank you very much].”
But Putin’s latest take, which came during a television appearance on 29 June, went quite a bit further, affording rare insight into how he thinks about the Jewish people. Essentially, he suggested that Slavic people take their cue from Israelis, and unite as one people in spite of different ethnicities, origins, and maternal languages.
In his annual live question-and-answer session cum news conference, Putin was asked why Russia hadn’t formally classified Ukraine as a hostile country in spite of the low-intensity war between the two countries since 2014.
“Because I don’t think that the Ukrainian people are unfriendly people to us,” the Russian leader replied, pointing out that Ukrainians and Russians “are generally one people”.
Putin went on to offer Israel as a model. “Look, Jews come to Israel from Africa, from Europe, from other countries of the world. Africans are black, yeah? People come from Europe – they speak Yiddish, not Hebrew. They seem to be unlike each other, but all the same, the Jewish people value their unity,” he said.
Putin has had strong emotional ties with Russian Jews that have been reflected in a series of favourable policies. Under Putin, the authorities have cracked down on antisemitic hate crimes, and Jewish communities have received the equivalent of millions of dollars in restitution for properties confiscated by the communists, helping to fuel a cultural and religious revival.
The earliest of those contacts was with a Jewish family who lived in his family’s apartment block in Leningrad, now St. Petersburg. They helped take care of Putin as a boy with his parents working long days.
“They were observant Jews who didn’t work on Saturdays, and the man would study the Bible and Talmud all day long,” Putin wrote in one of his biographies. “Once, I even asked him what he was muttering. He explained to me what this book was, and I was immediately interested.”
Another influential Jewish figure for Putin was his wrestling coach, Anatoly Rakhlin, who sparked the young Putin’s interest in sports and got him off the rough streets of Leningrad, where Putin would get into fights while his parents worked. At Rakhlin’s funeral in 2013, Putin reportedly was overcome by emotion, and ditched his security detail to take a short, solitary walk.
In 2014, during a visit to Israel, he met his former German teacher, Mina Yuditskaya Berliner, another influential figure in his life because she gave him the language skills that later helped him climb the ranks of the KGB (Committee for State Security). They had a two-hour chat in her rented apartment. Afterward, he bought the place for her. Berliner left Putin the apartment in her will, and it was returned to him after she died in 2018.
Russia’s two main Jewish communal organisations see Putin as a friendly force for Russian Jews. At the same time, tens of thousands of Russian Jews began leaving in recent years as Putin tightened his grip on the Russian media, courts, lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people, other minorities, and what little remains of freedom of expression.
As for the Israel comparison, Ukrainians tend not to agree that “Ukrainians and Russians are a single people.” One pro-democracy Kyiv news site called Putin a “broken record” on the topic.