Voices
Outside of the Bagel Belt
Last weekend the South African Jewish Board of Deputies held its national executive council (NEC) meeting. The NEC meets three times a year, and representatives from our councils around the country travel, some of them a long way, to be in the room. It is where we debate, argue a little, plan, and set our direction for the months ahead. This meeting was particularly robust, and I came away with a clear sense of where our energy needs to go next year.
Much of our time went to the Board’s policy and strategy on online and social media hate speech. This is one of the most complex areas of our work. Hatred online travels fast, crosses borders easily, and is often hard to trace to its source. As a community we need a clear strategy for dealing with online hate: where it comes from, the platforms that carry it, and what it leads to. The Cape Council has been particularly successful here, and much of the discussion focused on how we, as a national Board, can work together with them and align our strategies across the regions.
We were also joined by local elections expert Wayne Sussman, who took us through a deep dive into the election results and the coalitions likely to govern our cities and towns. Wayne is a communal treasure and, as I told the meeting, a true “nachas machine” for all of us. As the body responsible for the political representation of our community, the Board has to understand this new political landscape properly. New coalitions bring new people into office, and we need to engage with them effectively and build the relationships that make sure our voices are heard and our issues are dealt with.
The conversation I expect to shape our year most was about reclaiming public space. In the years since 7 October, the space Jews occupy in public life has slowly eroded. It did not happen all at once. Bit by bit, we have become more careful about where we gather and how visible we are when we do. The NEC put forward a clear call for our communities to take that space back.
Chanukah is a good place to start. Last year’s public lighting, held just after the Bondi tragedy, was exceptionally powerful. It would have been understandable for people to stay home, but instead we came out and lit together. This was a wonderful and emotional event and was attended by diplomats from embassies including Australia and the US. But it took place right in the middle of our own “Bagel Belt”. We were proud and we were visible, but mostly to each other.
That is a little ironic, given what Chanukah is about. The festival celebrates the rededication of a space that had been taken from us, and the custom has always been to place the menorah where passers-by can see it, so that the miracle is publicised rather than kept indoors.
Looking back over the weekend, I was struck by how often our discussions, whether about social media, coalitions, or a Chanukah lighting, came back to the same thing. Either we are present in the places where South African life happens, or we leave those places to others. In the coming year the Board will prioritise opportunities where we can reclaim our spaces across the country.



