Heartfelt apologies for anti-Semitic comments accepted
“So guys please don’t hate on them, they are sorry so let’s open them with big arms and let them say sorry [sic].” These are the words of King David Linksfield teenager Jordan Landsman, 16. Just last week, he came face to face with two Muslim teenagers who had made threatening and anti-Semitic comments on a WhatsApp group he administers.
After removing Muhammad Hattia, 19, and Tameez Seedat, 19, from his Sneakerheads WhatsApp group for writing hate-filled posts, he asked members of the group to re-invite them and accept their apologies.
This followed a meeting, held last Wednesday, where the SA Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) withdrew criminal charges against the two teenagers, following a settlement agreement between the parties.
“I felt they were genuine,” Landsman told the SA Jewish Report.
The attorney representing the Board, Ian Levitt, told the SA Jewish Report that the “settlement was necessary and important”.
He said: “I had to prevent a tit-for-tat laying of criminal charges and the potential outbreak of what could have been a very dangerous situation and a further flare-up of tensions in the Jewish and Muslim communities because of what was posted by various sides of the dispute on social media platforms other than Sneakerheads.”
The anti-Semitic posts were the culmination of numerous racial slurs on various social media platforms. These followed racial tension in the wake of the recent Gaza violence and the incident of TV personality and model Shashi Naidoo, who was forced to apologise after calling Gaza a “shithole”.
As soon as Hattia was re-introduced to the Sneakerheads group, he posted: “Hey guys my names [sic] Muhammad Hattia. I said some really disgusting and disgraceful things a while back and I really regret. I just wanted to formally apologise for all the fear and hurt I may have caused to all of you.”
Seedat posted: “Hi to everyone here, I’d just like to take this opportunity to apologise to everyone that had to see the comments I made about a month ago, was really insensitive of me to do so and I honestly mean no harm to anyone, I hope you all have it in you to forgive me for my mistakes. And to Jordan @Jordan Landsman, it was nice to finally sit down and meet you and your family, was a great experience bro.”
Their posts were followed by several others on the group accepting their apologies, and thereafter moving on with their usual takkie talk.
But while charges have been dropped and apologies have been made and accepted, all three teenagers have walked away completely changed young men.
They spoke to the SA Jewish Report this week.
Seedat, of Bedfordview, said he is “filled with regret and shame” for what he had done. “What happened was so uncalled for, so unnecessary… out of emotion. I interact with Jewish people every day at work and I had to explain to them. I have no hate. My parents were so disappointed in me, but I was more disappointed in myself.”
He said the meeting last week was “very inspiring, everyone was so nice and polite and we all expressed ourselves and told our sides”.
Hattia, who is studying law at the University of the Witwatersrand, told the SA Jewish Report that he couldn’t sleep at night, he felt so bad. “It was a very big mistake on my part and one that is going to stick with me forever. I realise it is completely unacceptable and I am very ashamed. My parents have never put into my mind any form of hate; our religion doesn’t teach us to be hateful.”
He said going forward, he wanted to help others become aware of the dangers of social media. “Social media can be very dangerous. It is easy to be misled. One has to be careful about what you read. Certain writers speak with so much passion, it is important to see both sides and hear from multiple people’s perspectives.”
He said he wished he could go back in time and “stop myself from saying those awful things out of raw emotion. I feel really, really ashamed.”
The national director of the SAJBD, Wendy Kahn, described the encounter last week as a “career highlight”.
“The young men were genuinely remorseful for what happened and wanted to make amends. Their family members showed a sincere desire to address whatever harm had been done and move forward in a spirit of peace and reconciliation.”
After meeting Seedat and Hattia, Landsman told the SA Jewish Report: “I believe they were genuine. Their fathers were very sad; one even cried.
“I’ve learned a lot from this. I was expecting horrible people who didn’t care. But when we came face to face I could see they did care.”
He said he was particularly moved by one of the fathers, who told those at the meeting that he had previously worked for a Jewish family for many years. “He was even a pallbearer at his employer’s funeral and would start his working day by having tea and breakfast with his boss’s wife every day.”
He added that the man cried at the meeting and said he was disgusted by what had happened and didn’t know why his son would do such a thing.
“People say such terrible things behind a screen, but when you see them they are completely different,” said Landsman. He also admitted to expecting to meet “horrible, nasty people”, but in reality they were teenagers just like him.
“I have no regrets for accepting their apologies.”
Members of the community were quick to criticise the SAJBD for what they believed was a weak response to the hate-filled attacks. Heavily criticising the Board on its Facebook page, some said it had failed the community by not making an example of the two men and not following through with legal action. Some described the Board’s response as a “pitiful, shameful, weak response”, using words like “disappointing, cowardly and insulting”.
Said one: “This was one time the Board should have prosecuted to the full to send a clear message that anti-Semitism will not be tolerated.”
The Board countered by saying the community was “better served with actions that bring about change”.
The Board maintained: “There was nothing flippant about the engagement. There was nothing but sincerity and genuine contrition in that room. Those boys followed the official apologies with heartfelt words. We are not a community that rejects genuine remorse.”
In the letters of apology, both men acknowledged that the comments they posted constituted racist defamation and incitement to cause harm against Jewish people. They apologised unequivocally to the South African Jewish community and, in particular, to the members of the Sneakerheads WhatsApp group. They agreed that “nothing justified what was said”.
Kahn, who has spent many years fighting hardened, unrepentant anti-Semites, said she honestly believed that the young men were “sincere and genuine and remorseful”.
In response to complaints on Facebook, she said that while many people had welcomed the resolution, some had reacted with “cynicism and anger”.
“They were not in the room where the humiliation and anguish was visceral and present. It was a difficult thing to witness, people having to own up to awful acts.
“An apology is not an easy action. It should never be underestimated how hard it is to take responsibility for your actions and to face those you have harmed. It is even harder in that the situation is so public.”
Kahn said the animosity that sadly exists between sections of the Muslim and Jewish communities “complicates the situation further”.
Yet despite this, she said, they went ahead with their apologies, with their fathers both supporting and adding to the sincerity of the engagement.
The young men will soon be spending time at the Johannesburg Holocaust & Genocide Centre.
Major parties undermined by “angrier, poorer” electorate
South Africans go to the polls on 1 November in “elections that no parties really want”, according to political journalist Stephen Grootes. In the midst of a pandemic, established parties are losing support “and people have become angrier and poorer” since the last local government elections in 2016.
Grootes was moderating a webinar on Tuesday, 12 October, titled “Navigate the local government elections 2021”, organised by the South African Jewish Board of Deputies. The webinar is part of the Board’s mandate to encourage voter registration in the Jewish community, formally observe the elections, and promote political debate.
Are these municipal elections about service delivery or about elements of identity in the context of South Africa’s racialised inequality? According to Nompumelelo Runji, the founder and chief executive of Critical ThinkAR – a research and stakeholder management consultancy – it’s a little bit of both in this highly polarised society.
“Good governance isn’t just about clean audits, sewage infrastructure, and tarred roads,” she said. For many, the yardstick is whether their quality of life is improving or not. They are asking if the African National Congress (ANC) can really deliver for all rather than the elite few.
Political analyst Dr Ralph Mathekga also senses popular anger, but no consolidation of support by any political party to capitalise on the ANC’s failures. “The ANC is held back by its own history,” he said, and hopes to get by on mea culpas [acknowledgement of wrongdoing] and faith. “It’s the devil people know,” Mathekga said. He judged that talk of renewal in the ANC was illusory, describing it as “a party in great difficulty”. “Corruption has been democratised in local government, with mammoth irregularities in public procurement,” Mathekga said, pointing out that criminal elements like protection rackets have filled the vacuum where the state has retreated.
Runji said local elections were “a vehicle for employment, a jobs pipeline for parties. Capacity and skills are trumped by factional allegiances. There is a failure to adhere to financial governance practices like the PFMA [Public Finance Management Act] and the MFMA [Municipal Finance Management Act].” She characterised the problem as a toxic mix of lack of responsibility, no accountability, deficient oversight, and a dearth of consequences for maladministration. “Party loyalty and dynamics become more important than delivering services,” she said.
Wayne Sussman, elections analyst for Daily Maverick, views it as a unique election in which the two major parties have little momentum 20 days before the vote.
“There are only 400 members of parliament, but there are far more council positions up for grabs,” said Sussman. In an environment of high unemployment, the prospect of a middle-class job for five years in a municipal council has proved enticing for many. Independent candidates have mushroomed, and he expects them to do marginally better because of their sheer volume. “They will find it hard to influence politics in the metros, but they will play a role in this election,” Sussman said.
Looking at opposition parties, will the Democratic Alliance (DA) be punished at the polls? A lot depends on differential turnout, according to Sussman. If the suburbs come out in numbers and disillusioned ANC voters stay at home, “the DA may not do that badly. It was the first out of the starting blocks with its posters. But to use a rugby analogy, with the try-line in front of them, they have had knock-on after knock-on in the past week.” He predicts that the party will retain Cape Town and be the biggest or second biggest party in all the country’s metropolitan councils.
“The DA seems to want to attract controversy and get into trouble, and the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) has no plans to co-operate with anyone,” Mathekga said. “It would be shocked if it actually won a council.” He agreed that the DA often failed to read the public mood, and didn’t appear to have a real strategy for the Gauteng metros. The EFF is growing in South Africa’s neglected small towns, and the party may emerge as kingmaker in several councils, like it did in 2016. But its refusal to commit to coalitions makes for unstable politics. There is the real chance that some councils will be deadlocked and unable to agree on the election of a speaker, a mayor, and to pass the council budget. If they fail to do the latter, they will come under national administration. The speakers predicted there may be chaos like this in Tshwane, the nation’s capital.
Sussman is also carefully watching the performance of former Johannesburg Mayor Herman Mashaba’s ActionSA, which has taken a gamble by contesting only in Gauteng’s three metros (Johannesburg, Tshwane, and Ekurhuleni) and in three municipalities in KwaZulu-Natal. It has run a slick social-media campaign. “He has to do well on election night,” Sussman said. “If he does badly, it’s probably the end.”
Finally, the panellists agreed there was merit in retaining separate municipal elections, as it promoted local-level democracy. This particular election will certainly make for interesting analysis in the weeks to come.
Back to Africa: shlicha’s journey comes full circle in Cape Town
Exactly 30 years ago, emissaries from the Jewish Agency came to Ethiopia to tell Batya Shmueli’s family that “the way to Jerusalem is open”. Soon after, at the age of 11, she made aliyah as part of Operation Solomon. Now, she has returned to the continent of her birth as a shaliach (emissary) of the Jewish Agency, closing the circle.
She and her husband, Hed Shmueli, and their three children arrived in Cape Town as shlichim the week before Pesach. She has taken on the role of aliyah and community shlicha while he is working as head of Israel education at United Herzlia Schools. With roots in Ethiopia, Romania, and Iraq, they bring the diversity of Israeli society to the southern tip of Africa.
“We always felt we would do shlichut in America or Canada,” says Shmueli. “But when we met Cape Town community leaders Esta Levitas and Julie Berman, we immediately connected and knew this was the community for us.”
It hasn’t been a simple journey. “When we were told we could come to Israel, my father was 81 years old. Every Jew in Ethiopia had waited for this moment. It was the first time I saw my father cry,” Shmueli recalls. The family had lived a difficult life, needing to hide their Jewish identity and battle for survival. While the flight was a moment of joy, adapting to life in Israel wasn’t easy.
“We lived in a caravan near a small town in the Galilee. After living there for three years, I attended boarding school. It was a tremendous culture shock,” she says. Wanting to blend in and be accepted, she threw off her family’s religious values and tried to become a secular teenager. “I even made my hair blonde!” she laughs. She learned Hebrew quickly, and tried to distance herself from her parents and her past.
But after school, she finally started to embrace her history and identity as an Ethiopian Jew. She found out that it was members of the Israeli Navy along with Mossad who had come to Sudan to help Ethiopian Jews come to Israel, and became inspired to join the navy during her army service to “close the circle”. Eventually, she served in the Israeli Navy with an elite naval commando unit.
“My father passed away before he could see me in uniform. So many people helped me in my journey in Israel. This was my opportunity to serve and give back,” she says.
It was in the navy that she met Hed whose family came to Israel from Iraq and Romania. He also had a connection to Africa. “After tragically losing his father, who was only 51 years old, he decided to take himself on a journey to discover the world. Being an artist and sculptor, he spent time as a volunteer arts project leader in Kenya, Ethiopia, and Eritrea, and learning traditional East-African wood carving in Kenya,” says Shmueli.
“After returning to Israel, the Israeli ministry of foreign affairs sponsored an artists’ mission to Dakar, Senegal. Hed was involved in co-ordinating and leading a group of Israeli artists sent as cultural representatives to Senegal for Israel’s 60th birthday celebrations.”
She also travelled after the army, spending a year in Los Angeles. It was there than she began to regret turning away from her identity and vowed “to return to my roots and culture”.
“I cried a lot that year, thinking about the pain and loss that my parents’ generation felt,” Shmueli says. “I wanted to go back to Israel and explain who we are as Ethiopian Jews. I wanted to be the voice of my parents.”
Returning to Israel, she realised she couldn’t “wait to be invited” to share her story, she had to just start doing it. She began to address audiences, sharing Ethiopian Jewish customs, culture, and cooking. She also got her Bachelor of Arts from Haifa University, where she studied teaching and the history of the Jewish people. She later received her Master’s degree in the history of Israel and Jewish law.
She then developed a programme that taught students about leadership and responsibility. In 2009, she returned to Ethiopia with the Israeli foreign ministry to teach village women about entrepreneurship. For the past 11 years, she has been fundraising for new immigrant populations.
When deciding where to raise their family, the Shmuelis chose to settle in the beautiful artists’ village of Ein Hod. It was a very secular community, however, so they decided to bring their passion for Judaism into the fold by commissioning a Sefer Torah for the village. It was made in the name of their late fathers, who had taught them to hold onto their Jewish heritage no matter what. “One thousand people came to the hachnasat [welcoming] Torah event,” recalls Shmueli. “There were Israelis from every sector of society.”
Eighteen years ago, they also opened their home to travellers hiking the Israel National Trail from the south to the north of Israel. Calling it “Avraham’s Tent”, they hosted more than 20 000 travellers.
The Shmuelis bring all of this passion and purpose with them to their shlichut in Cape Town. Their determination has seen them through delay in arrival as a result of the pandemic. In addition, their three children battled with being uprooted and being under lockdown.
“Israel is a country of children, and there is so much freedom for kids. So they have struggled, but we feel this is the best gift we can give them,” says Shmueli. “We are showing them that they belong to the Jewish people, and to bring that opportunity for connection to others.”
They believe they are in the right place at the right time. “After 20 minutes of talking to Esta and Julie, we looked at each other and said, ‘This is the correct place for us’. It’s a unique community with a unique history. This isn’t just about a new job, it’s something much deeper. We feel it’s the time to support the Jewish community.”
They have spent the past few months immersing themselves in the community and its organisations. “It’s so unique. It’s not every day that you see a community where all the Jewish children go to the same school and where there is so much support for everyone who needs it,” she says.
Just like she was given so many opportunities when she started her new life in Israel, she wants to create awareness about the possibilities that Israel provides, especially for the younger generation. She wants to help the youth feel proud of their heritage and connection with Israel.
“I want to be a bridge between Israel and South Africa,” she says. “We live our shlichut day and night, and are here for the community at any time. And we are here to learn from you too.”
They plan to meet people from all walks of life, sharing the diversity of their family and Israeli society. “We won’t apologise for who we are … we stand strong,” says Shmueli. At the same time, she encourages questions, discussion, and debate.
“The Ethiopian Jewish community never gave up on their dream of going to Jerusalem,” she says. Being part of the generation that got to go back to Israel means that she sees her shlichut as a continuation of that journey. “To be back in Africa as Israelis for the Jewish community – I thank G-d for showing us the way.”
Israeli company brings SA dam back to life
Just before Pesach this year, the SA Jewish Report detailed how leading global “watertech” company, BlueGreen Water Technologies, was assisting local government authorities to transform toxic water into healthy drinking water at Setumo Dam on the Molopo River in North West province.
Six months later, the company has announced that its water clean-up intervention has been successfully completed. For the first time in decades, the people of Mahikeng are receiving safe drinking water from their main water supply source, which was severely contaminated by toxic algae blooms. The project was in collaboration with Sedibeng Water, the company overseen by the Department of Water and Sanitation.
“BlueGreen is committed to making water safe,” says Eyal Harel, the chief executive and co-founder of the company. “We undertook this project pro-bono, knowing it was the only chance for this community to access clean drinking water, enjoy Setumo Dam as a safe water source, and unleash its potential for recreational purposes. We wish to empower local authorities to reclaim their water sources and advance the health and livelihood of their communities.
“To clear Setumo Dam was an unprecedented technical and operational challenge, with far-reaching consequences for the rural community that relies on it,” he told the SA Jewish Report. “The project has not only confirmed BlueGreen’s ability to remediate lakes under the toughest conditions, but also improved water quality and water availability. Setumo Dam can now be used not only as a source of drinking water but also as a local attraction for recreation. The economic development possibilities in and around the lake are far-reaching.”
The outbreak at Setumo Dam was considered one of the worst cases in South Africa. The heavy load of blue-green algae was the result of decades of insufficiently treated sewage being released directly into the dam. The dam’s size and level of contamination had deemed it “untreatable”.
BlueGreen’s treatment protocol was tailored to the unique conditions in Setumo Dam by BlueGreen’s field specialists. It also eliminated unpleasant taste and odour compounds from the drinking water.
“The unique situation we found in the field brought about two previously unaddressed challenges,” says Harel. “The first was the rural location and lack of basic infrastructure. This mandated an out-of-the-box logistical adaptation so that our treatment could be delivered timely and accurately.
“In addition, we encountered extreme biological conditions that rendered the entire dam a dead aquatic zone. Reviving the lake meant tailoring a specific treatment protocol that would reverse infectious processes that have been dominating the dam for decades, and give a fighting chance to non-toxic species that would enhance the lake’s biodiversity. As time went by, changes became evident from treatment, not only in the colour of the water, but a clear change in the number of animals, primarily birds, approaching the water, as well as an increase in their diversity.
“Shortly before starting treatment, we witnessed the local community performing rituals that involved entering Setumo Dam’s toxic water. We saw some fishermen trying to catch the few small fish that survived the harsh conditions. We grasped how under-developed the area was, in spite of its amazing potential. And we realised that once cleaned, we wouldn’t just improve the health and livelihood of the people around Setumo Dam, we would create a historical opportunity for local authorities to turn the lake into a place that could bring about much-needed development and prosperity.”
Asked if the company will work in South Africa again, Harel says, “As part of our work at Setumo Dam, we tried to establish an economic model that will allow us to repeat this in other under-developed areas in South Africa and around the world. We have established that a clean Setumo Dam saves the local community as much as 90% of their ongoing drinking water production cost! We hope that these findings will push other communities into action to reclaim and revive their water sources.
“Years of drought, pollution, growing population, and global warming have all contributed to South Africa’s deteriorating water availability and water quality,” he says. “Water has turned into a matter of national security. BlueGreen has made it part of its business to support local, rural communities, and establish their basic human right to clean water. Our means to remediate Setumo Dam’s water couldn’t have been put into play if not for the tremendous help of local government, including South Africa’s Department of Water and Sanitation and Department of Environment, Forestry and Fisheries, local water boards (Sedibeng Water and Rand Water), as well as the active support of our local partners, AECI group and Capitol Air. This united effort and commitment by so many is heartwarming, and an encouraging indication of South Africa’s innate ability to overcome great challenges.”
Jurgens van Loggerenberg, the director of Africa for BlueGreen Water Technologies says, “The project has had a positive impacted on more than half a million lives as a direct result of improved water quality. Setumo Dam’s high cyanobacterial cell content [billions of cells per millilitre] far surpassed the levels deemed safe and approved by the World Health Organization and the South African Bureau of Standards.
“The heavy organic load was also disrupting the ability of the local water treatment plant to operate, increasing the overall costs substantially and keeping the final water quality well below national and international standards. This historical achievement is the result of a joint effort that included the Department of Water and Sanitation, Sedibeng Water, and Rand Water Analytical Services working together.”
Letters/Discussion Forums1 week ago
Golden Acres yom tov services a shining light
Youth1 week ago
KDL ‘heritage swap’ a triumph
Sport1 week ago
Sixteen-year-old Club Champ cuts swathe on the green
Featured Item1 week ago
When music is a family matter, harmony is easy
Voices1 week ago
Board calls for practical implementation of hate-crime legislation
Voices1 week ago
Running with no-one chasing him
Community1 week ago
Pretoria rabbis ordained after challenging year
Community1 week ago
Chabad brings Sukkot to our doorstep