NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIPTION


click to dowload our latest edition

CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Letters/Discussion Forums

Herber House wasn’t perfect, but it served a purpose

Published

on

Bernard Lapidus, Toronto

Yes, it was tough living in buildings that weren’t designed to serve as hostels. Due to circumstances, we, the non-indulged, made do.

We had a makeshift soccer field, and a sand tennis court. Also a small grassed area, with no benches.

Herber House was established by the South African Jewish Board of Education at the request of Jews living in country areas who wanted a facility for their children to attend city high schools and a Jewish/Hebrew education, especially for boys, to prepare them for their Barmitzvahs. Anyone who celebrated their Barmitzvah in the little shul on the premises followed by a brocha luncheon, catered in-house, still holds fond memories of that day.

Rabbi Zaltsman and Mrs Dubin weren’t qualified to do their jobs. They adapted as they grew into them. Remember, it was just after World War II. Trained psychologists weren’t available, nor were suitably trained teachers. Yes, the meals weren’t the most appetising and in many cases, were inadequate, but circumstances dictate.

Imagine the responsibility of 120 kids, leaving at 07:00, Monday to Friday, returning between 13:30 and 17:30, catching public transport, some two buses there and two back, at about eight different schools. The furthest were Jeppe Boys and Girls High Schools in Kensington .The nearest were the Jewish Government School in Doornfontein and Barnato Park in Berea.

The matric results achieved by Herber House alumni, their achievements in their respective extramurals, as well as their success in later life says a lot.

The late former chief rabbi, Louis Rabinowitz, was originally opposed to the establishment of Herber House until he went to interview the headmaster of Maritz Brothers College about arranging for cheder/Barmitzvah lessons for Jewish boarders in the hostel. The response he got was, “We look after our own.” After that, he supported the establishment of Herber House.

The first four residents of the home, who arrived in April 1945, were the late Riva and Mannie Wainer, their brother Barney, now living in Israel, and Michael Yachad, living in Toronto.

Michael captained the Transvaal Under-19 rugby team before a badly broken leg ended his rugby career.

I was involved in organising the first house reunion in about 1990, and one in Israel in 2007. I also published a twice-yearly newsletter for many years.

Herber House served a most useful purpose as the only options at the time were a couple of boarding houses run by retired rabbis or the public-school hostels. The majority of us came from country areas from as far south as the Karoo all the way to the copperbelt in Northern Rhodesia/Zambia.

I started my school career boarding with the headmaster of the local school, and then spent three years at the convent. In those years, I learnt all about Jew hatred and anti-Semitism. Herber House, with all its flaws, was a breath of fresh air. Was I always happy there? No, but I made do. 

Continue Reading
2 Comments

2 Comments

  1. Harold Mograbi

    February 6, 2026 at 10:04 pm

    From the age of 6 years, 1951 I was the longest “inmate” at Herber House, 9 years of my life, which left indelible scars. It may have served a purpose, but sadly, those running the establishment were ill-equipped to handling of young children. Sadly, I have no good memories of those 9.years

  2. Gabriella Daniely

    February 26, 2026 at 4:16 pm

    I grew up hearing from my dad about how fundamental Herber House was and the friendships that he forged …lifelong friends that were like brothers due to the bond from “kicking the dust” on and in the dumps. What a wonderful surprise to find my late dad, Mannie(Emanuel) Wainer mentioned here cementing the storiesge passed on in many a conversation while growing up in Jhb. Despite all the harshness of the time, Zionist and Jewish values and identity were imparted at Herber House which evolved into my late dad’s love of Israel and my consequent aliya in 1980 fulfilling his ultimate dream.

Leave a Reply

Comments received without a full name will not be considered.
Email addresses are not published. All comments are moderated. The SA Jewish Report will publish considered comments by people who provide a real name and email address. Comments that are abusive, rude, defamatory or which contain offensive language will not be published.