IAW Day#1: “A pathetically poor show”
SAUJS’ “Give Peace Wings” campaign aimed at telling the true story in the face of the IAW campaign of US-based NGO Boycott, Divest & Sanction Israel would appear to have put the latter to shame on Monday. Read our reports from Wits, UJ, Stellenbosch and UCT, how Rhodes almost didn’t happen until the students saved the day, and the zaidas who went into the lions’ den at UJ…
SAJR Online will be running daily reports on the activities of Jewish students (SAUJS) backed up by organisational Jewry in their “Give Peace Wings” campaign aimed at telling the true story in the face of the Israel Apartheid Week (IAW) campaign of the US-based NGO Boycott, Divest and Sanction Israel (BDS).
And, by all accounts, the score after Day-one was Peace=1 and IAW=0 throughout the country. Read on for news from Wits, UJ, Stellenbosch, UCT and Rhodes.
A SAUJS member in the “Adam” tent
The SA Zionist Federation Cape Council chair Ben Levitas told SAJR Online today that “IAW put on a pathetically poor show at UCT on Monday.” Levitas says that all the IAW supporters could do was to “play the victims and shout that we rich Jews have a big fancy tent.”
While SAUJS’ effort at UCT was “quite amazing,” Levitas’ reading is that “IAW’s effort on campus was a complete flop!”
Take a bow SAUJS UCT
Carla Frumer is the National Zionist Officer for SAUJS and running anti-IAW activities on the UCT campus this week. Cape SAUJS chair Luigi Bonfig is running IAW at Rhodes until Wednesday (SEE BELOW).
LEFT: Two of the contingent of Israeli students, both of Ethiopian origin, in ‘Abraham’s tent’
Carla reports as follows from UCT: “Day One of IAW: in my opinion was a major success for us. We engaged with many students and had Israeli students from StandWithUs and some Israel-Ethiopian students help us out.
“We used last year’s idea of Abraham’s tent in order to create a comfortable, inviting and non-hostile environment on campus where students can discuss Israel in a constructive manner,” says Carla Frumer.
“The concept of Abraham’s tent comes from the bible: When Abraham lived in the desert he had a tent open on all sides and would invite weary travellers to rest in his tent.
“He would take care of them, make them feel welcome together with his wife Sarah, and would treat his guests with the utmost hospitality, humility and respect.
“This is the kind of atmosphere we hope to create during IAW,” she told SAJR on Monday evening, promising to keep SAJR updated. Carla also supplied the pictures.
After the fiasco over IAW which cost Rhodes dearly last year, SAUJS reformed a branch on the campus for the first time in many years.
But Rhodes looked like it was about to fall apart for SAUJS, said Levitas today, after the SAUJS organiser broke a leg. But that didn’t put the students off and SAUJS’ UCT chair, Luigi Bonfig – together with a member of the US group StandWithUs undertook what Ben Levitas described as “an epic journey” to Grahamstown.
Initially, says Levitas, Rhodes were not keen to allow the reinforcements on campus, nor were they prepared to let SAUJS put up posters.
That, too, didn’t daunt the students’ determination. They quickly established that BDS had put up posters without obtaining prior permission and, as they too were not sanctioned, Rhodes gave SAUJS permission to remove all of BDS’ posters.
SAUJS were eventually granted permission to erect a gazebo and distribute information on Israel.
Stellenbosch University decided to restrict IAW-related events on campus this year to just two events – IAW have an event this afternoon, which Levitas and some Israeli students are attending, and SAUJS get their chance to respond on Thursday afternoon. SAJR will report on both meetings.
Wits, too, was a damp squib
By all accounts the “Give Peace Wings” programme is far larger than that of IAW on SA’s most politicised campus. This is likely the result of the no-nonsense,
hard-hitting approach of Vice Chancellor professor Adam Habib who has launched a determined campaign to stamp out the hooliganism of the past.
SAJR photographer Ilan Ossendrywer said that the IAW representation on Monday was pitiful, while the SAUJS campaign was working wonders and attracting a lot of attention.
One of the coups for SA Jewry this year was bringing in ex-Ethiopian Israeli Jewish girls who are all officers in the IDF as well as students at an Israeli University. Ossendrywer said that he had seen a number of Muslim students engaging with the girls at Wits.
Launch of Israeli Apartheid Week in S.Africa with Simphiwe Dana, Mayor of Johannesburg Parks Tau, Former South African Ambassador to Israel, representatives of national organizations and others https://www.sajr.co.za/images/default-source/People/group/carno—arielahome.jpg” />By ARIELA CARNO,
The language we use and the way in which we frame a situation defines our everyday reality. If we frame something in the positive as opposed to the negative it is very likely to change the outcome of the situation; and that in principle is one of the underlying issues that I have with the week known as “Israel Apartheid week.”
Putting aside the fact that the claim that Israel is analogous to Apartheid South Africa is an insult to the very real struggle that the South African people underwent during Apartheid (in addition to being utterly false),the very title “Israel Apartheid week” presents a foregone conclusion that completely excludes the dialogue it claims to support.
This week rather than promoting a constructive dialogue regarding how a constructive solution can be reached in the Middle East incites hatred, violence and anti-Semitism. Now don’t wilfully misunderstand me-I am not saying that there are no issues in the Middle East, or that differences of opinion are not desirable, however creating a week of hate doesn’t solve any problems. It merely incites more hatred and violence and the cycle continues.
Every year on campus many students dread this infamous week because during it they feel that it provides a platform where criticisms evolve into discrimination. Hence this year the South African Union of Jewish students are running a campaign called give peace wings in the spirit of constructive dialogue, and we implore all students not to fall prey to the myth that hating those with a different opinion to yours is the only way to solve a conflict.
In the words of Nelson Mandela-“If you want to make peace with your enemy you have to work with your enemy. Then He becomes your partner”. So don’t fall prey to the rhetoric, rather join SAUJS wits in giving peace wings.
Lukud sent the ‘zaidas’ to UJ
On Monday night Likud-SA chair, Leon Reich together with members Sergio Kowensky and Basil Platzky attended a BDS-hosted talk at UJ by Israeli author Miko Peled who, said one SAUJS member who asked not to be named, “appears to be on a book tour to sell his books.” Peled wrote “The General’s Son.”
“His talk dealt with the history from 1948 as seen by the PLO and was full of inaccuracies,” Reich told the SAJR Online today, “he didn’t deal with Apartheid in SA and what he called Apartheid in Israel – he just made sweeping general statements.”
PICTURED LEFT: Zaida and
Likud-SA chair Leon Reich
Reich says the turnout was poor and there were 170-odd chairs and only 120 attended.
When it came to question time, says Leon, Basil stood up and called Peled a liar “and he told him that the information he was giving was wrong,” says Reich. “Sergio and I asked him not to get involved, but Basil said that he had come to insult Peled and he intended to do so.”
We were in the fourth row – the crowd behind us were in uproar. The chair and two members of the committee got up and waved their hands up and down to quieten the audience. The chair asked them to speak and through the chair.
After the meeting, says Reich, he went to speak to the chair, bought a book and gave his e-mail address after the chair assured him she would get him to see the real truth.
Israeli and US students at UCT Monday to support SAUJS
- The hashtag «#IsraeliApartheidWeek» has been a trending topic on twitter in South Africa today.
Teen vaccinate, or not teen vaccinate? Not a question, say doctors
As the news broke that South Africa would allow children aged 12 and up to get vaccinated with a first Pfizer shot, some parents were thrilled but others expressed fear, uncertainty, even anger.
“As the daughter of a polio survivor and the mother of an asthmatic child, I feel strongly that we need to get vaccinated, not just for ourselves, but for others,” says Vanessa Levenstein, a copywriter at Fine Music Radio in Cape Town. “My son, Sammy, is 14 and my daughter, Safra, is 17, and this past Shabbat, we all said how grateful we were that the vaccine was now available to them. I feel we are privileged to have it.”
Her husband, Jonathan Musikanth, an attorney, agrees. “We look forward to giving our children some sort of normality again,” he says. Levenstein adds, “We’re living in a society with huge social inequalities: someone living in a crowded Manenberg flat cannot self-isolate if they get infected. The only way to stop the spread is through the vaccine roll-out. ‘If I’m not for myself, who will be for me? And being only for myself, what am I?’ The words of Hillel still ring true.’”
The SA Jewish Report asked parents on Facebook what they thought, and a mother responded, “The judgement and anger towards people who don’t want to be vaccinated is extreme and frightening.” For this reason, she asked to be quoted anonymously.
“My children are healthy and have been exposed to COVID-19 and didn’t have any symptoms,” she said. “I don’t feel that I need to vaccinate them against something that I feel isn’t dangerous to them. They didn’t have any symptoms, so I don’t feel I need to protect them from dying. The fact is that nobody in the world knows the long-term effects of this vaccine. I’m not willing to risk it.
“It’s all well and good saying we should do it for herd immunity, but I won’t allow my children to get vaccinated to protect others when they don’t need the protection themselves,” she said. “Also, I don’t feel that 12 year olds are old enough to make a decision about this. My kids would agree.”
Asked how she felt about her children navigating a post-COVID-19 world unvaccinated, she said it was “a huge concern”.
“I’m concerned that their freedom will be taken away because of this. However, is that a good enough reason to go against what I wholeheartedly believe to be the truth about the vaccine?” she asked. “I don’t believe that by not vaccinating kids, I’m putting anyone else’s life in danger.”
Johannesburg pulmonologist and parent Dr Anton Meyberg told the SA Jewish Report, “This is definitely a scary and emotive time in our lives as parents. It’s one thing to vaccinate ourselves, the adults, but now we are being asked to trust science with our own children. Whereas we know that children definitely don’t get as sick as adults, they definitely can still get sick [from COVID-19]. And some get severe multisystem inflammatory syndrome while others can suffer from ‘long COVID’.
“There are so many myths and misconceptions about vaccination and they need to be dispelled,” he says. “As a doctor on the frontline, it’s a ‘no brainer’ to me that my daughter and children over the age of 12 should be vaccinated. As parents, we have the responsibility of safekeeping and caring for our children, and vaccinating them allows us to do this. No doubt by vaccinating our teens, we’re protecting their parents and grandparents, but we’re also making sure that schools can remain open and our children can lead almost normal lives.
“The most documented side effect in children after the second dose of the Pfizer vaccine, mainly in boys 16 to 30 years of age, is myocarditis [inflammation of the heart muscle],” Meyberg says. “Males aged 12 to 17 are more likely to develop myocarditis within three months of catching COVID-19 at a rate of 450 per million infections. This compares with 67 per million after the vaccine. The condition is self-limiting and easily treatable, and it’s crucial to avoid exercise for up to a week post vaccination in order to decrease the chances of its occurrence. Widespread vaccination is a critical tool to help stop this pandemic. The question shouldn’t be if you’ll vaccinate, but rather when.”
Jeffrey Dorfman, associate professor in medical virology at Stellenbosch University, says “the arguments for vaccinating children are very strong in countries such as South Africa and the United States where there’s still a lot of COVID-19 transmission and the potential for more waves. Children may be at lower risk of severe COVID-19 disease than adults, but not zero. In the United States, more than 63 000 children have been hospitalised since August 2020, and more than 500 have died. More than 4 000 have been diagnosed with multisystem inflammatory syndrome, which is dangerous.
“Additionally, the vaccines in use prevent many COVID-19 infections – not 100%, as we all know about breakthrough infections, but even for the Delta variant, vaccination prevents about 70% of infections based upon current studies,” he says. “That’s enough to matter to the people around children who are vaccinated, and may be enough to stop or reduce school outbreaks. Vaccination will certainly reduce the risk of a child bringing a COVID-19 infection home to vulnerable adults. It’s certainly not unheard of for children to bring an infection home from school resulting in the death of a caregiver, and this is tragic and preventable.
“Additionally, I know of cases of children who were asymptomatically infected and had to move away from vulnerable grandparents,” he says. “It was scary for the people involved. The children had no symptoms and were tested only because they had a COVID-19 positive contact. Were the contact not known, they would have continued to live with the grandparents, who would have been at risk. Even children who have had COVID-19 can have it again, and a large study from Kentucky in the United States shows that vaccination further reduces the risk of COVID-19 re-infection. We aren’t going to get on top of COVID-19 unless we use the tools at our disposal. As a society, we can’t afford serious lockdowns and have to use less disruptive tools. Vaccines should be high on everyone’s list.”
A third mother expressed mixed feelings about vaccinating her teenage sons. However, after reading a letter by Johannesburg family physician Dr Sheri Fanaroff, she has decided to go ahead with it. In the letter, Fanaroff laid out all the questions and concerns to show that “the risk of getting COVID-19 infection far outweighs the risk of vaccination in teenagers. I can say without hesitation that I will be relieved to have my own teenagers at the front of the queue to get vaccinated this week so that they can return to a more normal lifestyle.”
She explained amongst other points that “vaccination reduces the risk of teenagers dying: the virus was the fourth leading cause of death for those aged 15 to 24 and the sixth leading cause for those aged five to 14”.
Fanaroff also explained that “vaccination reduces the risk of severe infections, hospitalisation, and the need for oxygen and intensive care in teenagers. Recent figures from the US show that the hospitalisation rate among unvaccinated adolescents was ten times higher than that among fully vaccinated adolescents.
“There’s no biological reason or proof that a COVID-19 vaccine can interfere with the progression of puberty. There’s also no biological mechanism whereby hormones associated with puberty can have an impact on immune responses to COVID-19 vaccines. There’s no evidence that the vaccine has any impact on fertility.”
During the health department briefing on Friday, 15 October, acting Director General of Health Dr Nicholas Crisp stated that based on the Children’s Act that allows children aged 12 to 17 to consent to medical treatment, children in this age group don’t require their parents’ consent to have a COVID-19 vaccine. Teens can register and consent to being vaccinated without permission.
Hijacked mom warns motorists after being taken hostage
A Sandton mother of two was last week taken on a joyride from hell after being hijacked at gunpoint by two attackers at her local shopping mall in broad daylight.
Nicky Sher is always vigilant when it comes to her safety. Last Tuesday, 12 October, however, she was caught completely off guard when her assailants took her hostage as they made their getaway from the Morning Glen Shopping Centre in Gallo Manor.
“It was one of my worst nightmares come true,” she told the SA Jewish Report this week.
“It’s a different story being hijacked and left stranded without your car, that’s horrific enough, but being forcibly taken in the car takes it to another level.”
Sher arrived at the centre at about 12:20 to do a quick shop at the centre’s Pick n Pay and Mica Hardware. She parked outside the hardware store, and remembers thinking that there weren’t the usual number of eager car guards offering to help her when she emerged with her trolley a short while later. In fact, she didn’t see any.
“I thought that I could have done with the help as I had a heavy load of parcels which needed to be put into the boot of my car,” she said.
She also didn’t see any security guards on patrol, something that went through her mind fleetingly.
After offloading her trolley, she was about to climb into the driver’s seat of her seven-year-old white Mercedes Benz CLA 200, when the two men “came out of nowhere”. They somehow forced her into the passenger side of the vehicle as one man took the driver’s seat while the other one sat behind with a gun pointed towards her.
“I started screaming for help. I screamed and screamed,” she said, but the men fled the centre at high speed with no regard for whatever was in their way, bumping into things.
“I saw a flash of a car guard and another man who I believe reported his suspicions to centre management.”
In the blink of an eye, a petrified Sher found herself trapped inside her own car with two crazed men who threated to shoot her if she continued to scream. The driver made a sharp right onto Bowling Avenue, driving at high speed.
“I continued to scream, I didn’t know what else to do,” she said, pointing out that in hindsight, she knows it wasn’t wise as the men continued to threaten to shoot her.
A few hundred meters after Kelvin Drive, in the direction of South Road, Morningside, she saw a metro traffic police road block up ahead, and felt hope and relief. “I thought Hashem was watching over me, and I was going to be rescued. I even tried to open the door, which caused the driver to become very agitated,” she said.
Her relief soon turned to disappointment and dismay when the police seemingly did nothing to stop her attackers from hurtling away after they had half-heartedly tried to flag the speeding vehicle down. “That’s when I knew I was on my own. Strangely, I became calm at that moment,” she said, even though her life flashed before her.
“It’s going to sound weird, but all I could think about was Mark Kopelowitz, who was murdered the day before.” (Kopelowitz was killed after walking into an armed robbery taking place at his jewellery store at the Centurion Mall on Monday, 11 October.)
“I thought yesterday it was Mark, today it’s going to be me,” she said. “I tried to calm down because screaming and trying to open the car door hadn’t worked. I begged them to let me out, told them I was a mother, hadn’t seen their faces, and couldn’t identify them.”
She was forced to hand over her handbag with all its belongings inside. They wanted the pin numbers of her credit cards.
“I couldn’t remember one of them, and they said they’d shoot me if I told them the wrong numbers,” she said.
She assumed they’d drive to the nearest ATM and keep her hostage until they had withdrawn as much money as they could. Instead, they hastily stopped the car on the corner of Marlboro Drive and Lilium Street, Marlboro, and told her to get out.
She ran towards the nearest garage and frantically told the owner she had been hijacked.
It was then that she called her husband, Clifford, and her two daughters.
“It’s a family trauma when something like this happens. Everybody is shaken,” she said.
She decided to tell her story as a warning to other motorists to be extra vigilant, especially when approaching one’s vehicle at shopping malls.
She believes they targeted her for her car.
Sher took part in a Zoom security meeting with centre management last week, and relayed her story. She was told that according to CCTV footage, her attackers watched her drive into the centre and had casually followed her to see where she parked. They waited for her on a low wall in the underground parking. They wore peak caps so as not to be recognised by cameras.
“I know I had protection from above because I escaped relatively unscathed and I’m here to tell the tale. But we get so complacent especially at the centres we go to often. It’s important to be aware of your surroundings at all times, get in your car, lock the doors, and drive away quickly without bothering with things like Bluetooth and music.”
She said that since the incident, she has been overwhelmed with support from total strangers, family and friends. “It has been life affirming.”
Shopping malls have become hotspots in Johannesburg, and this isn’t the first time that hijackings have taken place at this centre.
CAP Chief Operating Officer Sean Jammy said this week, “This unfortunate incident underlines the need for competent security to be in place in any environment we frequent. To mitigate the threat and impact of this type of incident, we encourage all community members to practice situational awareness. Ensure that your family can track you via a cell phone platform, and that vehicles have tracking installed. Try and let people know where you are, and what time you should be returning.
“Be aware of risks in your environment. If anything looks suspicious, treat it as a threat and remove yourself from harm’s way. Most importantly, create an alert as early as possible, and train your family and those that care about you to do the same.”
At the time of going to press, the centre management hadn’t responded to questions about increasing security measures.
Habonim’s return to machaneh ‘a dream come true’
The Habonim Dror slogan “Don’t call us thy children, call us thy builders”, rang true this week, when the Jewish Zionist youth movement announced that it would hold a machaneh this December, taking the brave step of building something new and vibrant in a post-pandemic world. Machanot were cancelled last year for the first time in decades – a huge blow to movement morale.
In a video titled simply, “We are going home”, Habonim announced on Sunday, 17 October, that after 23 months of waiting, a machaneh will finally be held at its Onrus campsite. It will be called “Lachlom Mechadash” (To Dream Again) because the movement sees it as a dream come true. It will be shorter (from 9 to 20 December), with fewer people, and everyone will need to be vaccinated.
Rosh Machaneh Aaron Sher explained how this dream became a reality. “From the moment our va’ad poel [steering committee] for machaneh was elected this year, we were thinking about how we could make machaneh a reality. After consultation with medical professionals and those who have had summer camps overseas, many permutations of machaneh were drawn up.
“Some were on the more optimistic side, and some with more conservative thinking,” he says. “Throughout this time, the South African Zionist Federation [SAZF] was holding meetings for the youth movements, the Community Security Organisation [CSO], and other community figures to discuss how machaneh could happen, often attended by [local virology expert] Professor Barry Schoub. A common point was the vaccination of adolescents. It left room for optimism for December. Without these meetings and the support of these communal bodies, December machaneh couldn’t happen.”
With the announcement on Friday, 15 October, that vaccination would open to 12 to 17 year olds in South Africa, “the va’ad poel and our staff were in a panic, but excited. A golden opportunity had fallen into our laps that would allow us to bring machaneh to fruition. It’s almost impossible to describe the happiness we felt.”
Asked about the impact of not having machaneh or in-person events, Sher says, “In a word, devastating. Habonim Dror thrives on in-person interaction. For generations, we have been a space for Jewish youth to come together to have fun, discuss world issues, create change, and become strong leaders. Online activities don’t bring the ‘Habo magic’ that we need to feel.”
Habonim Manhig Wayne Sussman says, “The impact of not having a machaneh last year or any major in-person events has been absolutely devastating. Not just to Habonim, but to all South African youth movements. Camps and in-person events are a core part of the South African Jewish youth experience. They’re one of the things which make our community so great, and it’s absolutely critical that our kids return to camp sooner rather than later.”
Since the announcement, he says, “I have seen a youth movement come alive. I’m seeing renewed vigour, renewed energy, which has been lacking amongst our very brave and committed youth movement leadership for the past 20 months.”
Sher says “a full COVID-19 protocol policy document has been prepared for our machaneh with the help of medical professionals and those who have successfully run summer camps overseas. This will be available as soon as our sign-ups are open so that all parents and madrichim know exactly how we are keeping safe before they sign up.”
Says Sussman, “Of course, we’ll also limit numbers, and we are going to launch this properly and open sign-ups only once we’ve properly engaged with community leadership and the CSO.”
“Vaccination will be required by anyone on the campsite, a negative COVID-19 PCR test will have to be presented on arrival, and general COVID-19 protocols will have to be adhered to,” Sher says. “Anyone who tests positive will have to isolate immediately and will unfortunately be sent home. Those who have been in close contact with them will have to isolate and await a PCR test.”
What will stay the same and what will be different? “Fortunately, with a vaccine blanket over our campsite, a lot of what we love about machaneh can continue,” says Sher. “There will still be ruach [spirit], Havdalah, the beach, and everything we love about machaneh, just with some slight adjustments.” The youngest age groups, Garinim and Shtilim, won’t be able to attend.
“Should there be a fourth wave during December, Habonim Dror is committed to ensuring that we are able to adapt or at worst cancel,” he says. “The safety and health of our campers will always come first. We will make sure that we make the correct decisions in the interest of our community.”
Says Sussman, “Of course, there’s a chance that we might have to pull the plug on this. But as long as that door is open, as long as kids know that if they get vaccinated, if they’re responsible, and if they really want to attend machaneh, we’re going to do what we can to give them best summer.”
Since making the announcement, “We have had an overwhelming response from parents, kids, bogrim, and ex-chaverim all over the world,” says Sher. “People have been reaching out offering support and services. I couldn’t be more thankful to our Habonim and Jewish communities. We’re going home.”
SAZF executive member Anthony Rosmarin says, “December machanot have, for decades, played a vital role in strengthening Jewish identity and building young leaders. Recognising the impact that COVID-19 has had on the ability to host these pivotal annual events, the SAZF created a platform that brought together youth movements, medical and security advisors, and stakeholders to discuss the feasibility of December machanot.
“Given the fluid nature of the ongoing pandemic, this assessment is continually being updated and we recognise that each youth movement must come to its own determination as to whether or not to move forward with camp preparations for 2021. We are committed to providing support and advice on how best to approach this complex decision in a safe and responsible manner.”
The mazkir of Netzer South Africa, Jason Bourne, says “Netzer has decided that it won’t be running a full, in-person summer machaneh this year. Instead, we will be running day camps in Cape Town, Durban, and Joburg. Though vaccinations are being administered and cases are declining, we feel that there are still too many unanswered questions to have a sleep-away camp. As things unfold and more people are vaccinated, we may open a small weekend sleepover element to our day camp experience for older, vaccinated participants only.”
A community leader, speaking anonymously, says “Bnei Akiva would love to have a camp at the end of the year but it’s looking at all the medical and logistical issues. No decision has been made and over the next few days, it will explore it all carefully and come to a conclusion.”
Banner1 week ago
SA warmly welcomes Palestinian foreign minister
News1 week ago
Jeweller’s senseless murder leaves community reeling
News1 week ago
Desai “dismissive and unapologetic” about breaching code
Featured Item1 week ago
Israeli company brings SA dam back to life
Featured Item1 week ago
Back to Africa: shlicha’s journey comes full circle in Cape Town
Featured Item1 week ago
Major parties undermined by “angrier, poorer” electorate
Voices1 week ago
Challah – bread of Jewish men’s affliction
Voices1 week ago
Rebuilding hope and rewarding service