Subscribe to our Newsletter


click to dowload our latest edition

CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

News

SA’s anti-Israel hypocrisy held to account

Published

on

“Massacre, carnage, butchering, and ethnic cleansing,” were just some of the ways that the African National Congress (ANC) described Israel’s defensive actions in Gaza over the weekend. This was while more than 1 100 missiles were launched into Israel by the Gaza-based terror group, Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ), over the weekend. Many of these missiles (about 200 of them) fell short of the Gaza border, killing Palestinians in Gaza.

The ANC’s statement came shortly after equally extreme remarks from the department of international relations and cooperation (Dirco), which said that “the killing of children by the Israeli government must urgently be addressed”.

Minister of International Relations and Cooperation Naledi Pandor’s remarks clearly insinuated that Israel was deliberately targeting youth, in spite of the fact that it was rockets launched from Gaza that killed Palestinian children.

This was confirmed by Prime Minister Yair Lapid’s spokesperson, Keren Hajioff, on 6 August. “Tonight, Islamic Jihad terrorists in Gaza fired a rocket towards Israeli children but ended up killing Gazan children instead.” According to media reports, 16 Palestinians lost their lives because 200 PIJ missiles fell within Gaza over the weekend.

“We’ve become all too used to gross displays of hypocrisy on the part of Dirco, but with this latest demonstration, Minister Pandor has sunk to a new low,” says Wendy Kahn, the national director of the South African Jewish Board of Deputies. “She has shown one set of standards for the Jewish State and another for the rest of the world. It makes a mockery of South Africa’s pretensions to being a moral voice on the global stage.

“Six months and tens of thousands of civilian deaths later, we’re still waiting for Dirco to condemn Russia’s barbaric war of aggression against the Ukrainian people,” Kahn says.

“By comparison, within hours of clashes breaking out on the Israel-Gaza border, Pandor rushed to issue yet another virulent denunciation of the Jewish State.

“South Africa evidently has no problem with most countries defending themselves against violent Islamist extremism. In fact, South African troops have been fighting that very scourge just across our border in Mozambique. When it comes to Israel defending its citizens against terror by the PIJ, however, it appears as though our minister has little sympathy for Jewish lives.

“One waited in vain for our government to express condolences when dozens of Israelis were killed or injured in a wave of terrorist attacks earlier this year. As always, all expressions of outrage were reserved solely for condemning Israeli acts of retaliation.”

Regarding the ANC’s statement, Kahn says, “It’s regrettable that the ANC, with his proud history of peace building and reconciliation, has betrayed these principles. The hypocrisy and double standards have destroyed the credibility and integrity it once upheld. By singling out of the Jewish State for its hate and venom, it makes a mockery of these values. This bizarre rant distresses not just the Jewish community, but all South Africans who oppose hate.”

The South African Zionist Federation (SAZF) also released a strong statement in response to Pandor’s words on Gaza. “The SAZF notes that the South African government has jumped on the opportunity to bash Israel for doing what any responsible country would do to protect its citizens against senseless terror and violence,” said SAZF spokesperson Rolene Marks.

“PIJ, an Iranian proxy operating in Gaza and the West Bank, has been responsible for horrific terror attacks and murder of hundreds of innocent Israeli citizens. PIJ has been designated a terrorist organisation by the United States, European Union, Japan, United Kingdom, and others. Israel has taken action to prevent PIJ from carrying out further barbarous acts.

“Israel has a moral obligation to protect Israeli citizens,” said Marks. “Instead, the South African government is misconstruing the situation so as to signal to anti-Western sentiments that place our country at odds with the modern world. Not one word has been said by South Africa to condemn the double war crimes PIJ commits each time it fires rockets and mortars from civilian areas in Gaza towards civilians in Israel. We call on the South African government to clarify why it’s taking the side of an international pariah organisation responsible for the killings of innocents,” she said.

The SAZF also condemned the ANC statement. “The extent to which the ANC has recklessly ignored the key factors of the recent conflict cannot be overstated. It refuses to consider the danger in which PIJ has placed civilians during attacks by selecting firing locations in densely populated urban areas. Israel, on the other hand, has gone far beyond the expectations of a modern military to reduce civilian casualties. This includes evacuating buildings, aborting strikes on PIJ leadership, and utilising Israel’s Iron Dome to protect urban areas.

“The ruling party ignores its laundry list of domestic failures. Instead, the ANC shifts the focus to a conflict which has no impact on the lives of South Africans. Where Egypt, a fellow country in Africa, acted to broker a ceasefire and save lives, the ANC government has simply fanned the flames of hate. The ANC’s deplorable hypocrisy should be condemned in the strongest possible terms.”

“It seems as though most of the South African state at institutional level has largely abandoned any effort to be even remotely even-handed on Israel,” says local political analyst Daniel Silke. “It’s possible that much of this is pre-December ANC conference bluster in which Israel provides a useful base to rally the ANC troops. But at the moment, South Africa isn’t attempting to look more critically at events on all sides.”

Hussein Solomon, senior professor in the department of political studies and governance at the University of the Free State, says, “Dirco seems to be trapped in a time warp. The ANC is in an existential crisis and all it can do is cling to the memory of the anti-apartheid struggle. If it really wants to make a difference, it should be seen to be engaging objectively, neutrally, and dispassionately with both sides.”

Continue Reading
2 Comments

2 Comments

  1. Peter

    Aug 11, 2022 at 2:21 pm

    It is totally iniquitous that we have to constantly listen to the biased diatribe coming from Pandor. She is clearly unfit to hold the position she is currently in. There seems to be no moral and ethical standards and total disregard for South African citizens. She is totally out of her depth, chooses not to be informed but selectively makes unfounded comments and does absolutely nothing to assist in any compromise whatsoever.
    She should be dismissed from her position which should be awarded to a well informed educated and pragmatic
    person elected for the greater good of the people and not just hers and ANC interests. I am totally embarrassed
    at the poor calibre of person she is as indeed many other people in authority who should not be there, B. Cele for one instance.

  2. yitzchak

    Aug 14, 2022 at 7:20 am

    When domestic policy fails, countries look outwards to find a distraction from home failures e.g.
    Our train system
    Our power system
    Our airlines(govt
    Our public health mismanagement.
    Our water supply

    So Israel becomes the scapegoat.To boost flagging morale.

    The successes in Israel of all the above failures in RSA make me proud all of which could be fixed with Israeli help and knowhow.The foreign policy contortionists and
    bigotry confirms that SA has an amoral attitude to foreign policy.
    One thing is for sure… Minister Nadia Pandor could do with a free subscription at Star Fitness, while emaciated beggars beg for food…..even a cooldrink with sugar.

    The only good thing is the effluent management in Gauteng…it all flows into the Hartebeestpoort dam.
    (Free fertilizer for the farmers ,excellent veggies and fruits,AND ONE HELLUVA SMELL)

    2022 will be a decisive year for the ANC and will make Israeli coalition politics look like a panda bear picnic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *