5 Comments

1. 

   bernadine stein

   Aug 13, 2014 at 6:53 pm

   ‘He should be sent back where he cane from and face all charges  he certinaly not welcome her are his followers  so sad too send helpless children to beg  very sad   !!:.’

   Reply
2. 

   Atty. David Cohen

   Aug 14, 2014 at 9:58 am

   ‘There is no precedent that the Interpol will seek to arrest a person on the type of offenses attributed to Rabbi Berland, especially since he was not convicted of anything but only wanted for questioning.

   There are lots of convicted fugitive criminals and murderers in South Africa, living there for years, and nobody is looking for them. This indicates that Rabbi Berland is marked due to some objective and goal for which a complete system is in operation to chase him all over the world as we have already seen (and this can be done by people with lots of money and power), and therefore it is clear that even if he will come for investigation he will not be given a fair trial.’

   Reply
3. 

   david

   Aug 17, 2014 at 2:16 am

   ‘I would imagine that Israel’s request to S A , to extradite Rabbi Berland , is the surest way to guarantee that he will not be sent back. With the current vitriol by the ANC  against Israel, they will certainly never accede to any request , legal or otherwise. I would imagine that the S A government will grudgingly accept him as an unwelcome visitor, which he already is, to many of the Jewish community. ‘

   Reply
4. 

   Sam

   Aug 22, 2014 at 4:38 am

   ‘Does South Africa have an extradition agreement with Israel? Not sure about that. Maybe the South African government should arrange one with their friends in Gaza – the Palestinians and their brothers that represent Hamas since those are their claimed and arm in arm ally’s from the middle east and not the Israelis.  My guess is that our corrupt Government should give Rabbi Berland asylum, and with it a suitable house in Waterkloof with all the trimmings and bags of cash – as they do with other known and wanted ‘bad elements’ from all over the world. Perhaps hide him at Nkandla????
   ‘

   Reply
5. 

   Samuel Shalom

   Aug 26, 2014 at 9:03 am

   ‘@bernadine stein 13 Aug said: He should be sent back where he cane from and face all charges  he certinaly not welcome her are his followers  so sad too send helpless children to beg  very sad!!\”

   Bernadine if you would know something about the history of Jewish migration to South Africa from the earliest days whether from Western or Eastern Europe you would know that there were so many proud crooks, skilled horse-thiefs, admitted army deserters, uncaring bigamists, frauds galore that if each and every one of them would have been sent back to the European \”police\” that was hunting them, then thousands of people would have been rounded up and put on boats heading straight for the Gulags.

   Think of Australia that started out as an official British penal colony where criminals and gangsters were sent away, and South Africa, while not a penal colony, nevertheless was home to any rogues that could get here by hook or by crook and go deep enough into the country not to be caught because they tried to make something of themselves. There are books that mention many of these kinds of characters and their stories.

   In those olden days Jews welcomed Jewish strangers into their midst and did not hand them over to the police which was a worse fate than community shunning which could be done if need be.

   Since when is Israel the paragon of moral justice where presidents are forced to resign in disgrace and serve jail terms? Corruption is everywhere. While Rabbi Berland may not be a saint by a long shot, he is no worse than some other rabbi sex offenders friends of the Chief Rabbi who are not excoriated and hunted the way Berland is. What the Chief Rabbi is afraid of, as his supporters admit, is that the \”homeostasis\” in the community will be \”disturbed\” but what they really mean to say is that it is a direct challenge to the Chief Rabbi’s ability to be the \”numero uno\” & \”chief honcho\” in SA Judaism because Berland is without a doubt a very famous (notorious?) rabbi than the Chief Rabbi. In other words what they call a \”true rival\” and as such must be confronted, captured, eliminated and sent away!

   This is about power and not much else. So far it is a stalemate between Berland and the Chief Rabbi but SA Jewry should not stand aside and cluck cluck about \”poor\” Jewish children begging but should do something proactive, positive and helpful about it. Give the adults jobs! Practice charity and loving-kindness to fellow-Jews. Don’t judge them. You are not God! Don’t let them sit outside in the cold or heat or rain. Even prisoners have human rights. Certainly the Breslovers and their children deserve fair treatment and Jewish charity in the spirit of the way Abraham our forefather welcomed strangers even if he knew they were idol-worshipers and pagans he saw it as his duty to help them and raise them and in turn create a bond with God between all of them.’

   Reply